33. A
Case for Anatomic Correction in Atrioventricular Discordance? Effects of
Surgery on Tricuspid Valve Function
Marjan Jahangiri*, Andrew N.
Redington*, Martin J. Elliott*, Jaroslav Stark, Victor T. Tsang*, Marc R. de
Leval, London, United Kingdom.
Discussant: Tom R. Karl, M.D.
OBJECTIVE:
To assess tricuspid valve function
in atrioventricular discordance (AVD) following palliative procedures
(pulmonary artery banding and Blalock-Taussig shunt) and corrective procedures
(anatomic correction, AC; physiologic correction, PC).
METHODS:
Tricuspid valve dysfunction was
assessed by transthoracic echocardiography and graded into no regurgitation
(0), mild (1), moderate (2)and severe (TR) before and after 150 operations
performed in 99 patients with AVD who underwent surgery between 1988 and 1999.
The ventricular arterial connection was discordant in 92% and double outlet
right ventricle in 8%. 66% had a VSD and 28% had pulmonary stenosis. Twenty six
patients underwent pulmonary artery banding and 25 had a modified
Blalock-Taussig shunt performed. Eighty patients underwent PC and nineteen
underwent AC (atrial-arterial switch, n=15; atrial-Rastelli, n=4).
RESULTS:
Table I summarises patients with TR
and the effect of surgery on this (3 in the PC group had tricuspid repair and 4
had replacement). The operative mortality in patients who underwent PC was 7%
as compared to no death in the AC group (p=0.59).The median follow-up was 3.2
years (range; 3 months-10.2 years).
CONCLUSIONS:
Volume loading (shunt) or right to
left septal shift (PC) worsens TR whereas volume reduction (banding) or left to
right septal shift (AC) has beneficial effects on tricuspid valve function.
Anatomic correction can be performed with a low morbidity and mortality in
selected patients with AVD and provides superior functional result.
Operation, N
|
Preop TR Score mean±SD
|
Postop TR Score mean±SD
|
p-value
|
|
Pulmonary Artery Banding, 20
|
1.83±0.72
|
0.86±0.55
|
<0.001
|
|
Blalock-Taussig Shunt, 16
|
1.59±0.80
|
2.42±0.61
|
<0.001
|
|
PC, 27
|
1.50±0.69
|
1.05±0.94
|
NS
|
|
AC, 15
|
1.59±0.87
|
0
|
<0.001
|
Graham Fellow, 1973-1974
*By Invitation
TUESDAY MORNING, MAY 2,
2000
7:00 a.m. C.
WALTON LILLEHEI RESIDENT FORUM SESSION
Supported by an unrestricted
educational grant from St. Jude Medical, Inc.
Constitution
Hall, Metro Toronto Convention Centre
(8
minute presentation, 7 minutes discussion)
Moderators: Eric A. Rose, M.D.
Edward D. Verrier, M.D.
L1. Gene Transfer of Bcl-2 Does Not Affect
Myocardial Stunning But Ameliorates the Deletorious Effects of Chronic
Remodeling
Allan
S. Stewart*, Henry L. Zhu*, Derek R. Brinster*, Hugh L. Sweeney*, and Timothy
J. Gardner, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
OBJECTIVE: Numerous studies implicate apoptosis as an important
consequence of ischemia/reperfusion injury. However, no study reproducibly
associates the reduction of apoptosis with an improvement in post-ischemic
myocardial function. Data is lacking to determine if apoptosis is advantageous
to organ survival or deleterious to myocardial function. This experiment
employs gene transfer of bcl-2 to significantly reduce apoptosis and correlate
that reduction with acute and chronic measurements of contractility.
METHODS: An adenovirus encoding for bcl-2 was constructed and
injected into the lateral wall of 20 New Zealand white rabbits. 20 rabbits
recieved adenolac-Z as a control. Five days post-injection, the rabbits were
subjected to 30 min or proximal circumflex occlusion followed by reperfusion.
10 rabbits in each group underwent four hours reperfusion, while the remaining
underwent 6 weeks of reperfusion. Functional measurements were obtained with
echocardiography, aortic flow probe measurements, and sonomicroscopy. Infarct
percentage was assessed with TTC staining. Histological analysis was performed
with HandE, trichrome staining, and TUNEL assay. Gene expression was assessed
with Western blot and RT-PCR.
RESULTS: Bcl-2 reduced
the percentage of apoptotic cells from 19.2±3.5% to 4.1±1.7% (p<.05).
However, this decrease did not result in a significant improvement in
contractility, ventricular stroke work, or ejection fraction in the acute
group. In contrast, bcl-2 was found to significantly improve regional wall
motion, ejection fraction, stroke work, and enhanced diastolic relaxation in
the chronic group. A decrease in fibrosis, cell-cell slippage, and ventricular
wall thickness was seen in the bcl-2 chronic group, but not seen in the acute
group.
CONCLUSIONS: Apoptosis was demonstrated after reperfusion injury
but had no influence on post-ischemic myocardial stunning. However, apoptosis
was found to adversely influence chronic remodeling and ventricular function.
Gene transfer of bcl-2 may be a useful strategy to protect the heart from the
deletorious consequences of apoptosis induced remodeling.
*By Invitaiton
L2. Epidermal
Growth Factor Augments Post-Pneumonectomy Lung Growth
Aditya K. Kaza*, John A. Kern*, Stewart M. Long*,
Victor E. Laubach*, Joshua A. Tepper*, Kimberly S. Shockey*, Curtis G. Tribble,
and Irving L. Kron, Charlottesville, Virginia
OBJECTIVE: We
hypothesized that post-pneumonectomy compensatory lung growth can be augmented
by the administration of exogenous epidermal growth factor (EGF).
METHODS: Adult Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into three
groups. Sham left thoracotomy was performed in the first group (C), left pneu-monectomy
in the second group (P), and left pneumonectomy with administration of EGF
(0.2ug/g, at 72 hour intervals) in the third group (P¢). The right lung growth
was studied in each group at 1, 3, 5, 10 and 21 days after surgery. Wet lung
weights were measured. Volumetric analysis was performed using saline
displacement technique after intra-tracheal instillation of 2% glutaraldehyde
to a pressure of 25cm. Lung weights (g) and volumes (cc) were expressed as a
ratio to the total body weight (kg) (lung weight and volume indices).
RESULTS: Using ANOVA, we noted a significant increase in lung
weight index between the P and P' group at 21 days (3.61 vs 4.62, p=0.006).
Contrast analysis also revealed a significant increase in lung weight index
between P and P' at 3 days (2.75 vs 3.08, p=0.034). Lung volume index was
evaluated using ANOVA, which showed significant increase in right lung volume
between the P and P' groups at 5 (15.09 vs 16.98), 10 (18.81 vs 24.48) and 21
(21.01 vs 28.54) day intervals (p<0.001).
CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that administration of
exogenous epidermal growth factor has a significant impact on
post-pneumonectomy lung growth. This process may be mediated by an
up-regulation of growth factor receptor expression in the contra-lateral lung
after pneumonectomy. We believe that this is the first demonstration that adult
lung growth can be exogenously enhanced.
*By Invitation
L3. Early
Sustained Reduction of Pulmonary Angiotensin-Converting Enzyme Activity
Following Superior Cavopulmonary Anastomosis in the Lamb
Sunil P. Malhotra*, V. Mohan
Reddy*, Frank L. Hartley and Kirk Riemet, San Francisco, California
OBJECTIVE:
The Glenn shunt is a superior
cavopulmonary anastomosis (SCPA) widely used for palliation of various forms of
congenital heart defects. However, pulmonary arteriovenous malformations
(PAVMs) of varying clinical significance develop in 15-60% of patients
following surgery. Histological analysis of these PAVMs reveals the
proliferation of numerous dilated, thin-walled vessels. To assess alterations
in regulators of vascular tone following SCPA, changes in
angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) activity and plasma angiotensin II (AT-II)
levels were examined.
METHODS: Lambs, aged 30-40 days, underwent an end-to-end
anastomosis of the superior vena cava to the right pulmonary artery. In age
matched controls, a sham operation was performed. PAVMs developed in all SCPA
lambs by 6 weeks after surgery, as demonstrated by contrast echocardiography.
Animals (n=16) were then studied at various time points following surgery. ACE
activity was measured in lung homogenates. Levels of AT-II in the right
pulmonary vein were measured by ELISA.
RESULTS: Compared to controls, ACE activity in the right lung
of Glenn animals was reduced 86% at 4 and 14 days, 52% at 50 days, and 13% at
133 days following surgery. This correlated with a 70% reduction in AT-II
levels in SCPA animals studied at 4-14 days following surgery, while levels at
50 and 133 days approached control levels.
CONCLUSIONS: ACE activity is an indicator of endothelial
integrity. Diminished activity following SCPA suggests pulmonary endothelial
damage. Moreover, the resulting decrease in AT-II production, a pulmonary
vasoconstrictor, may promote chronic dilatation of the right pulmonary vascular
bed. The role of these perturbations of the affected vasculature in PAVM
formation remains to be determined.
*By Invitation
L4. Should
Mediastinal Drainage Be Autotransfused Postoperatively in the Cardiac Surgery
Patient?
John
S. Thurber*, Edward R. Zech*, Loretta Aiken*, and Gary H. Meyers*, Bethesda,
Maryland
OBJECTIVE: Autotransfusion (AT) of mediastinal drainage in the
post-operative cardiac surgery patient has been a method of perioperative blood
conservation for over 20 years. The risks and benefits of this practice have
been reviewed in a number of reports, with conflicting results. This study
prospectively evaluates the risks/benefits of the use of AT.
METHODS: A prospective, randomized study of 128 patients
undergoing elective cardiac surgery was performed. Patients were randomized
into one of two groups: the experimental group received autotransfused
mediastinal drainage (AT) for 6 hours after surgery (n=62), and the control
group was treated with standard chest drainage with no AT (n=66). Both groups
received homologous blood transfusion when the hemoglobin fell to less than 8.0
g/dl. Pre- and post-operative variables recorded included: hematocrit,
platelets, PT/PTT, fibrinogen and d-dimer levels, and homologous blood products
infused.
RESULTS: Packed red blood cells were required in 9 of 62
(15%) patients in the AT group, and in 14 of 66 (22%) patients in the non-AT
group (p=ns). Total homologous blood
product exposure was slightly higher in the non-AT group (25% vs. 19% AT, p=ns). Pre- and post-operative hematologic parameters
were similar between the two groups. D-dimers were elevated in the serum of 11%
of AT patients, compared with 3% of non-AT patients (p=0.03). There was an
increased cost for nursing effort and equipment involved with the AT patients.
CONCLUSIONS: The use of AT in the postoperative cardiac surgery
patient did not result in significant reduction in the use of homologous blood
products, and did result in increased cost. Therefore, in the setting of
routine blood conservation practices, the postoperative use of AT in the
cardiac surgery patient is not recommended.
*By Invitation
L5. Subdiaphragmatic
Venous Hemodynamics in the Fontan Circulation
Tain-Yen
Hsia*, Sachin Khambadkone*, Francesco Migliavacca*, and Marc
R. de Leval, London, United Kingdom
OBJECTIVE:
To investigate Subdiaphragmatic
venous physiology in Fontan patients (FP) in order to understand some of the
early and late problems and to improve their management.
METHODS:
Doppler flow were evaluated in
subhepatic inferior vena cava (IVC), hepatic vein (HV) and portal vein (PV)
with respiratory monitoring and a tilt table to assess effects of respiration
and gravity. 19 controls (group A) and 44 FP, 29 in functional class 1 (group
B)and 15 in class 3 (group C), were studied. IVC, HV and wedged-HV (WHV)
pressures were measured during catheterization in 11 controls and 8 class 3 FP.
Difference between HV and WHV is the transhepatic venous pressure
gradient(TVPG).
RESULTS:
Shown below, ratio of inspiratory/expiratory
antegrade flows (R)represented effect of respiration. Gravity effect was
evaluated by a ratio of flow rates in supine/upright positions (G). * denotes
p-values <0.05, <0.0001, # =0.07.
CONCLUSIONS:
This is the first time hydrostatic
force have been evaluated in FP. Gravity reduced class 1 FP's IVC and HV flow;
progression to class 3 did not exacerbate this. In the PV, while FP have lost
normal expiratory augmentation to flow, gravity more adversely influenced class
3 than class 1 FP. This poorer flow dynamics is coupled to higher splanchnic
pressures and a lower gradient. Reduced TVPG in class 3 FP further suggests the
hepatic sinusoidal reserve is impaired, creating an open tube phenomenon. These
observations may account for some late gastrointestinal problems in FP.
|
FlowRatio
|
R (IVC)
|
R(HV)
|
R(PV)
|
G (IVC)
|
G(HV)
|
G(PV)
|
|
Avs.B
|
1.2 v 1.6
|
1.7v 2.9*
|
0.8 v 1.0*
|
1.2 v 1.8*
|
1.7 v 2.3#
|
1.9 v 2.1
|
|
Bvs.C
|
1.6 v 1.5
|
2.9 v 3.1
|
1.0 v 1.1
|
1.8 v 1.7
|
2.3 v 2.4
|
2.1 v 3.1*
|
|
Pressures mm Hg
|
IVC
|
HV
|
WHV
|
TVPG
|
|
|
|
Control vs Fontan
|
6.2±2.0 v
|
5.9±1.9v
|
8.4±2.9 v
|
2.5±2.4 v
|
|
|
|
|
13.7±3.7
|
15.7±5.0
|
15.0±4.0
|
0.5±0.7 *
|
|
|
1973-74 AATS Graham Fellow
*By Invitation
L6. Laparoscopic
Gastric Ischemic Preconditioning Prior to Transhiatal Esophagectomy
Sandra
M. Jones*, Daniel Gagne*, Mary Beth Malay*, Dennis L. Fowler*, Robin S.
Macherey* and Rodney J. Landreneau, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
OBJECTIVE: Cervical esophagogastric anastomotic disruption
following THE is a significant problem. Ischemia of the "proximal gastric tip"
is a primary cause of anastomotic failure. We sought to determine if gastric
blood flow could be improved with the preoperative performance of LAP ischemic
preconditioning, by selectively ligating the short gastric (SG) or the left and
short gastric (LG/SG) blood supply to the stomach 3 weeks prior to THE.
METHODS: Fifteen 25 kg mongrel dogs underwent a 2 stage
experiment of LAP followed 3 weeks later by THE. Prior to each stage,
hemodynam-ics were stabilized. Blood flow was assessed using the fluorescent microspheres
method. Three groups were separated into 5 dogs each. Group 1 LAP alone, group 2 LAP/ligation of SG only, group 3 LAP/ligation
of LG/SG. Microsphere injection occurred prior to pneumoperitoneum and at
completion of LAP. All 15 dogs underwent THE 3 weeks later. Microsphere blood
flow injection was made after anesthesia and after esophago-gastic anastomosis.
All animals were euthanized and gastric perfusion (near anastomosis) was
analyzed. Differences in blood flow were evaluated using Student's T test.
RESULTS: The mean baseline blood flow was 0.58ml/mg tissue.
After THE, proximal gastric blood flow fell to 19% of baseline(0.11ml/mg) in
the control (group 2), to 31%(0.18ml/mg)
in SG (group 3), and to 59% (0.34ml/
mg)in LG/SG (growp 3). This relative
preservation of blood flow among the LG/SG group was significant compared to
the control group 1(0.11ml/ mg vs
0.34ml/mg, p=0.02)Preoperative ligation of SG vessels alone (group2) did not
provide significant "ischemic conditioning" improvement in proximal gastric
blood flow following THE.
CONCLUSIONS: Ischemic preconditioning of the proximal stomach
during preoperative LAP can significantly improve blood flow to the "gastric
tip" prior to THE. Future consideration of this procedure during LAP staging of
esophageal carcinoma may be considered to reduce anastomotic complications
following THE.
*By Invitation
§L7. Assisted Venous Drainage Presents Risk
of Undetected Air Microembolism
Angelo
LaPietra*, Eugene A. Grossi, Bradley A. Pua*, Rick A. Esposito*, Aubrey C.
Galloway, Christopher C. Derivaux*, Lawrence Classman* and Stephen B. Colvin,
New York, New York
OBJECTIVE:
Methods for minimally invasive
cardiac surgery rely on augmented venous return (AGVR) techniques (kinetic or
vacuum) for cardiopulmonary bypass. Such techniques can introduce venous air
emboli (AE) which can pass to patients. We examined this potential with
different AGVR techniques.
METHODS:
An in vitro bypass system was
created using kinetic (Biomedicus Pump) (K-AGVR) or vacuum (hardshell
reservoir) (V-AGVR) systems. Roller or centrifugal pumps were used on the
arterial side with a fiber oxygenator and a 37m arterial filter. Air was
introduced into the venous line via an open 25g needle. Test conditions
included varying the amount of venous negative pressure (-15 to 75mmHg), AGVR
type, and arterial pump (AP).
RESULTS:
Changes in negative venous pressure
did not affect the number of microbubbles introduced into the system. K-AGVR
filled quickly with micro and macro bubbles requiring manual clearing.
Microbubbles/ min (mean±SD) are shown below for the venous inlet,
pre-oxygenator, and patient side of the arterial filter.
CONCLUSIONS:
Some AGVR configurations permit a
significant quantity of microbubbles to reach the patient despite filters.
Centrifugal pump has air handling disadvantages when used for K-AGVR, but aids
in clearing AE when used as the arterial pump. The surgeon using these
techniques should be aware of the potential risks and how to minimize them.
|
|
Venous Inlet
|
Pre-Oxygenator
|
Patient Side
|
AP: Roller
|
|
|
|
|
V-AGVR
|
9754±2898
|
16±21
|
010
|
|
K-AGVR
|
10004±1258
|
14218±905
|
817
|
|
AP: Centrifugal
|
|
|
|
|
V-AGVR
|
8639±2987
|
249±690*
|
010
|
|
K-AGVR
|
9806±2758
|
1317±3311*
|
0+0
|
§Authors have a relationship with Heartport,
Baxter Healthcare, St. Jude Medical & Medtronic
*By Invitation
L8. Hemodynamic
Changes During Beating-Heart CABG Surgery
Quoc-Bao
Do*, Olivier Chavanon*, Pierre Couture*, Andre Denault*, Raymond Carrier*,
Montreal, PQ, Canada.
OBJECTIVE:
To study the effect of different
manipulations during beating-heart CABG, we monitored the systemic arterial
pressure (SAP), the pulmonary arterial pressure (PAP), the mixed venous oxygen
saturation (SvO2) and the cardiac output (COI)on 54 patients who
underwent complete revascularization. Five patients also had a transoesophageal
echocardiography (TEO) to assess mitral valve dynamics and ventricular
function. Mean patient's age was 66.4±9.2 years, and 3.3±0.8 distal anastomosis
were performed per patient.
METHODS: Stabilization of the heart were done using a
"fork-type" stabilizator, and the target coronaries were clamped proximally and
distally to the anastomosis site without preconditioning.
RESULTS: Changes in SAP, PAP, SvO2 and COI, as
shown in this table, occurred during the stabilization period preceding
coronary anastomosis.
CONCLUSIONS: The mobilization and stabilization of the heart
rather than clamping the coronaries, were responsible for some minor
hemody-namic changes during beating-heart CABG surgery. The marked elevation of
PAP during LAD and DG revascularization suggests that compression of left
ventricle outflow tract may be the cause.
|
|
LAD
|
DG
|
MG
|
RC(PDA)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Clamp (min)
|
9.5±0.4
|
7.4±0.3
|
8.3±0.4
|
8.6±0.6
|
|
ΔSAP (%)
|
-8.6±2.9
|
-14.0±4.9
|
-16.3±2.0
|
-15.1±2.5
|
|
ΔPAP (%)
|
23.9±4.6
|
37.7±14.4
|
12.5±5.3
|
12.7±3.8
|
|
ΔSv02(%)
|
-8.5±1.2
|
-8.1±0.7
|
-6.5±1.4
|
-9.6±0.6
|
|
ΔCOI (%)
|
-4.2±2.9
|
4.5±2.8
|
-6.3±1.9
|
-2.6±1.7
|
No correlation between Sv02, COI, SAP, PAP and clamping time
were found. They were no significant mitral regurgilation on TEO, although some
diastolic and systolic regional dysfunction were found during left anterior
(LAD) and the diagonal (DG) coronary clamping.
*By Invitation
9:00 a.m. SCIENTIFIC
SESSION
Constitution Hall, Metro Toronto Convention Centre
Moderators: Delos M. Cosgrove, M.D.
Tirone E. David, M.D.
34. Late
Results of Aortic Valve Sparing Operations
Tirone
E. David, Susan Armstrong*, Joan Ivanov*, Christopher M. Feindel, and Gary
Webb*, Toronto, ON, Canada
Discussant: Magdi H.Yacoub, M.D.
OBJECTIVE: To determine the late results of aortic valve
sparing operations in patients with aortic root and/or ascending aortic
aneurysms.
METHODS: All patients with aortic root and/or ascending
aortic aneurysms who had aortic valve repair have been followed prospectively
at annual intervals. The mean age of 161 consecutive patients operated on from
July 1987 to June 1999 was 54+17 years, range 16 to 84 years. Forty-two
patients had the Marfan syndrome according to Gent criteria. Thirty-one
patients had type A aortic dissection, 15 had mega-aorta syndrome, 34 had
coronary artery disease and 9 had mitral regurgitation. The technique of
reimplantation of the aortic valve was performed in 48 patients and remodeling
of the aortic root in 113. The follow-up was complete and ranged from 0 to 134
months, mean of 34±28.
RESULTS: There were
3(2%) operative and 16(10%) late deaths. Cardiovascular events were the cause
of death in 15 of 19 patients. Actuarial survival at 10 years was 80%±5% for
all patients and 100% for those with the Marfan syndrome. Aortic dissection and
mega-aorta syndrome were independent predictors of death. The most recent
Doppler echocardiogram showed trace or no aortic insuffiency (AI) in 77
patients, mild in 70, moderate in 8, and severe in 3. The 3 patients with
severe AI were reoperated on uneventfully. The freedom from moderate or severe
AI was 85%±5% at 10 years. Aortic root remodeling and the need for repair of
cusp prolapse were associated with a higher risk of AI (p=0.03). The freedom
from reoperation was 98%±1% at 10 years.
CONCLUSIONS: Aortic valve sparing operations to treat aortic
and/or ascending aortic aneurysms provide excellent and lasting functional
results in patients with normal aortic cusps including those with the Marfan
syndrome.
*By Invitation
35. Repair
Is Preferable to Replacement for Ischemic Mitral Regurgitation
Per
Nils Wierup*, A. Marc Gillinov*, Eugene H. Blackstone, Delos M. Cosgrove, Ehab
S. Bishay* and Patrick M. McCarthy, Cleveland, Ohio
Discussant: D. Craig Miller, M.D.
OBJECTIVE:
To determine whether mitral valve
(MV) repair is preferable to MV replacement for ischemic mitral regurgitation
(MR).
METHODS:
From 1985 to 1997, 402 patients
(pts) with ischemic MR underwent either MV repair (n=339) or MV replacement
(n=63), Myocardial infarction (MI) was acute in 24% and remote in 76%. By
multivariable logistic regression, pts were more likely to receive a repair if
they were male (P=.04), had chronic
ischemic MR (P=.001), underwent
non-emergency operation (P=.002), had
restricted leaflet motion (P<.0001), or
underwent ITA grafting (P=.002). These
factors were used for propensity matching. Factors associated with early and
late mortality were identified by multivariable, multi-phase hazard function
analysis.
RESULTS:
Hospital mortality was 11%. The
timing of MI and operative strategy influenced hospital mortality (table). In
propensity-matched pts, survival after MV replacement was 76%, 60%, and 43%
after 30 days, 1 year (yr), and 5 yrs. In contrast, survival after MV repair
was 91%, 80%, and 60% at these same time intervals (P=.003). Risk factors for death within the first yr of
operation included older age (P=.002), greater
wall motion abnormality (P=.006), and
replacement rather than repair (P=.0005). All
pts were predicted to benefit from repair; however, the benefit became more
pronounced with advancing pt age and less apparent in pts with more severe
heart failure (P=.001). Freedom from
repair failure was 93% at 5 yrs.
CONCLUSIONS:
For surgical management of ischemic
MV regurgitation, MV repair is the treatment of choice.
|
Hospital
Mortality (%)
|
|
Time of Infraction
|
Repaired (%)
|
Total
|
Repair
|
Replace
|
P value (repair vs. replace)
|
Acute
|
71
|
22
|
17
|
35
|
.1
|
|
Remote
|
87
|
8
|
5
|
30
|
<.001
|
|
P value
|
<001
|
.002
|
.009
|
.7
|
|
*By Invitation
36. Induction
Chemoradiation Plus Surgical Resection Is Feasible and Highly Effective
Treatment for Pancoast Tumors: Initial Results of SWOG 9416 (Intergroup 0160)
Trial
Valerie
W. Rusch, John J. Crowley*, Michael J. Kraut* and David R. Gandara*, New York,
New York; Seattle, Washington; Detroit, Michigan; Sacramento, California
Discussant: Douglas J. Mathisen,
M.D.
OBJECTIVE:
Rates of complete resection (50%)
and 5 year survival (30%) for Pancoast tumors have not changed for 30 years.
However, combined modality therapy has improved outcome in other Stage HI
non-small cell lung cancers. This prospective intergroup trial tested the
feasibility of concurrent inducton chemoradiation and surgical resection in
mediastinoscopy negative Pancoast tumors with the ultimate objective of
improving resectability and overall survival.
METHODS:
Patients with pathologically proven
T3-4 N0-1 Pancoast tumors received 2 cycles of cisplatin and etoposide
chemotherapy concurrent with 45 Gy radiation. In patients with no evidence of
disease progression thoracotomy was performed 3-5 weeks later. Two cycles of
chemotherapy were given postoperatively.
RESULTS:
From 4/95-9/99, 116 patients were
entered on study. This analysis includes 101 eligible patients, 71 men and 30
women with a median age of 56 yrs. Induction therapy was completed as planned
in 93% patients with 2 Grade 5 and 17 Grade 4 toxicities (predominantly
cytopenia). To date, 81 patients have undergone thoracotomy with the most
common procedure being lobectomy + chest wall resection. 1 patient died
postoperatively. A pathologic complete response (pCR) occurred in 57.5%
patients and 63% rumors were downstaged. At 1 year overall survival was 77% for
T3, 80% for T4 tumors; at 3 years 50% for both T3 and T4 tumors. Most common
site of relapse was the brain.
CONCLUSIONS:
1) This combined modality approach
was highly feasible in a multi-institutional setting; 2) pCR rates were
unexpectedly high; 3) resectability and overall survival are improved compared
to historical controls; 4) improved outcome was especially notable for T4
tumors which usually have a grim prognosis.
*By Invitation