The American
Association
for Thoracic
Surgery
78TH ANNUAL MEETING
May 3-6, 1998
Hynes Convention
Center
Boston, Massachusetts
MONDAY, MAY 4, 1998
8:00 a.m. BUSINESS SESSION (Limited to
Members)
Ballroom, Hynes Convention Center
8:15 a.m. PLENARY SCIENTIFIC SESSION
Ballroom, Hynes Convention Center
Moderators: Floyd D. Loop, M.D.
James L. Cox, M.D.
1. THIRTY YEARS OF CARDIAC
TRANSPLANTATION AT ONE INSTITUTION.
Robert C. Robbins, M.D.*, Clifford
Barlow, M.D.*, Philip F. Oyer, M.D., Sharon A. Hunt, M.D.*, Bruce A. Reitz,
M.D., Edward B. Stinson, M.D. and Norman E. Shumway, M.D.
Stanford, California
Discussant: Bartley P.
Griffith, M.D., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
We
reviewed the records of all 865 patients (pts) who have received a cardiac
transplant (Tx) at our center. Patients were divided into 3 groups (Gps) based
on immunosuppression (IMS) received: Gpl = no cyclosporin (CSA) (n = 200,
1/68-11/80), Gpl = CSA (n = 269, 12/80 - 5/86), Gp3 = CSA + OKT3 (n = 396,
6/86-10/97). Important data relating to the groups are as follows (mean ± SD):
|
|
Gp1
|
Gp2
|
Gp3
|
|
Recipient
age (years) (range)
|
38 ± 12 (12-55)
|
39 ± 14 (0.1-63)
|
42 ± 19 (0.1-70)
|
|
Donor age
(years) (range)
|
22 ±6 (13-41)
|
23 ± 7 (1-53)
|
27 ± 12 (0.5-54)
|
|
Wait list
time (days)
|
44 ± 35
|
49 ± 69
|
157 ± 195
|
|
Length
hospital stay (days)
|
69 ± 36
|
36 ± 23
|
21 ± 34
|
|
Time to
first rejection (days)
|
36 ± 55
|
63 ± 175
|
95 ± 259
|
Actuarial
analyses of short and long-term outcomes for the Gps are as follows:
|
|
3 months
|
1 year
|
5 years
|
10 years
|
15 years
|
p value (ANOVA)
|
|
Survival (%)
|
Gp1
Gp2
Gp3
|
82
87
91
|
63
80
83
|
36
59
66
|
22
39
50
|
17
22
-
|
p < 0.05
|
|
Death from
rejection (%)
|
Gp1
Gp2
Gp3
|
2
2
2
|
10
5
3
|
15
7
6
|
17
8
7
|
17
8
-
|
p < 0.05
|
|
Death from
infection (%)
|
Gp1
Gp2
Gp3
|
14
6
3
|
29
9
6
|
47
17
10
|
51
28
14
|
55
32
-
|
p < 0.705
|
|
Death from
lymphoid malignancy (%)
|
Gp1
Gp2
Gp3
|
-
-
-
|
-
-
-
|
2
2
1
|
9
5
2
|
13
8
-
|
NS
|
|
Death from
coronary artery disease (%)
|
Gp1
Gp2
Gp3
|
-
-
-
|
-
-
-
|
4
10
8
|
11
19
10
|
16
31
-
|
NS
|
Retrospective
HLA typing did not affect outcome. There are 141 pts who have survived > 10
years with the longest survivor being 23 years post Tx. There have been 65
re-Tx in 63 pts with 1, 5, and 10 year actuarial survivals of 51, 25, and 18 %
respectively. Conclusions: The evolution of three decades of experience with
cardiac Tx has resulted in an improved overall survival of pts who are
currently at both extremes of age, wait longer for Tx, and have more complex
medical conditions. The incidence of death from infection and rejection has
decreased with time as a result of improved IMS and treatment. Continued
advances in peri-operative management and IMS could further refine this initial
Tx experience and improve the survival and quality of life of pts with
end-stage heart failure.
*By
invitation
2. RESULTS OF FIRST 100 CASES OF
COMPLETE REPAIR OFCONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS IN PATIENTS WEIGHING700 TO 2500
GRAMS.
V. Mohan Reddy, M.D.*, Doff B.
McElhinney, M.S.*, Theresa Sagrado, B.A.*, Andrew J. Parry, M.D.*, David F.
Teitel, M.D.*, Norman J. Silverman, M.D.* and Frank L. Hanley, M.D.
San Francisco, California
Discussant:
Roger B.B. Mee, M.B., Ch.B., Cleveland, Ohio
Infants
born with congenital heart disease are more likely than normal children to be
small for gestational age at birth. Published data suggest that low birth
weight is a risk factor for corrective surgery for many cardiac defects.
Congenital heart defects in this patient population are typically managed with
supportive therapy or palliative surgery, and definitive repair is delayed.
However, the morbidity of such an approach has been shown to be high. Since
1990, complete repair of congenital heart defects (other than isolated patent
ductus arteriosus) has been performed in 102 infants ≤ 2500 g (median
2100 g, range 700-2500 g), including 16 who weighed ≤ 1500 g. Defects
included ventricular septal defect with other left to right shunt lesions (23),
tetralogy of Fallot (19), transposition complexes (13), coarctation of the
aorta (12), interrupted aortic arch (9), truncus arteriosus (8),
atrioventricular septal defect (6), total anomalous pulmonary venous return
(4), and other defects (8). Preoperative morbidity was more common in patients
who were referred late for corrective surgery. Standard techniques of neonatal
cardiopulmonary bypass were used, including circulatory arrest in 17 pts. There
were 10 early deaths (10%), due to cardiac failure (4), arrhythmia (1), sepsis
(1), idiopathic coronary artery intimal necrosis (1), foot gangrene (1),
pulmonary hemorrhage (1), and technical error (1). No patient had evidence of
post-bypass intracerebral hemorrhage. At a median follow-up of 36 months, there
had been 6 late deaths and 7 patients had undergone surgical and/or catheter
reintervention for subaortic stenosis (2), conduit obstruction (2), pulmonary
artery stenosis (2), or recurrent coarctation (1). Among the first 50 patents,
followed for > 3 yrs, there was no evidence of neurological sequelae. Median
weight for age was at the 20th percentile, with a direct correlation between
weight for age and birth weight (p = 0.01). In most cases, delay in repair of
congenital heart defects in low and very low birth weight infants does not
confer any benefit and is associated with a higher incidence of preoperative
morbidity. Complete repair of both simple and complex congenital heart lesions
can be performed successfully in low and very low birth weight infants with
good early and medium term results. Postoperative growth is accelerated
following repair and approximates the normal growth curve for low birth weight
infants without congenital heart disease. It is recommended that such infants,
especially when symptomatic, undergo early surgical correction rather than
prolonged medical management or other forms of palliation.
*By invitation
3. CLINICAL EXPERIENCE WITH CARINAL
RESECTION.
John D. Mitchell, M.D.*, Douglas J. Mathisen, M.D.
Dean M. Donahue, M.D.*, Ashby C. Moncure, M.D. John C. Wain, M.D.*, Cameron D.
Wright, M.D. and Hermes C. Grillo, M.D.
San Diego, California and
Boston, Massachusetts
Discussant: Jean DesLauriers,
M.D., Sainte-Foy, Quebec, Canada
Pathologic
processes that involve the carina pose a tremendous challenge to thoracic
surgeons. Techniques have been developed to allow primary resection and
reconstruction. The procedures are demanding, management of patients complex,
and the potential for complications high. Few institutions have accumulated
sufficient experience to allow meaningful conclusions about indications and
contraindications for surgery, morbidity and mortality rates. Since 1962 135
patients have undergone 143 carinal resections (134 primary resection, 9
re-resection) at our institution. Indications for carinal resection included
bronchogenic cancer (58), other airway neoplasms (60), benign or inflammatory
strictures (16). Thirty-seven patients had prior lung or airway surgery not
involving the carina. Carinal resection without pulmonary resection was
accomplished in 52 patients; 57 patients had carinal pneumonectomy (44 right,
13 left); 14 patients had carinal plus lobar resection; and 11 patients had
carinal resection following prior pneumonectomy (9 left, 2 right). There were
15 different combinations of reconstruction. Techniques were employed to reduce
anastomotic tension. The overall mortality in the 134 patients for primary
carinal resection was 12.7% (17/134). Adult respiratory distress syndrome was
responsible for 9 early deaths. Significant multivariate predictors of
postoperative death included length of resected airway, development of
anastomotic complications, and postoperative mechanical ventilation.
Complications occurred in 35 patients (26%) including atrial arrhythmias (17),
anastomotic complications (9) end pneumonia (7). Mortality by procedure and
indication for surgery was as follows.
|
|
Right
|
Left
|
Carina
|
Carina
|
Prior
|
Carinal
|
Lung
|
Other
|
Benign
|
|
|
Carinal
|
Carinal
|
alone
|
& Lobe
|
Pneu-
|
Re-resect.
|
Cancer
|
Neoplasms
|
Strictures
|
|
|
Pneumon.
|
Pneumon.
|
|
|
Monect.
|
|
|
|
|
|
N
|
44(7)
|
13(4)
|
52(4)
|
14(1)
|
11(1)
|
9(1)
|
58(9)
|
60(5)
|
16(3)
|
|
Mortality
|
15.9%
|
30.8%
|
7.7%
|
7.1%
|
9.1%
|
11.1%
|
15.5%
|
8.3%
|
18.7%
|
Left
carinal pneumonectomy is associated with high operative mortality and
consideration of the underlying pathologic process and chance for long-term
survival must be carefully considered before recommending such a procedure.
Carinal resection with preservation of lung and for low grade neoplasms is
associated with acceptable mortality rates. Chance for long-term survival must
be carefully balanced against operative mortality in recommending carinal
resection for lung cancer.
*By invitation
4. PRIMARY AORTIC VALVE REPLACEMENT
WITH HOMOGRAFTS OVER 25 YEARS: VALVE AND PROCEDURE RELATED DETERMINANTS OF
OUTCOME.(106)
Ole Lund, M.D., Ph.D.*, Magdi
Yacoub, F.R.C.S., DSc., V. Chandrasekaran, F.R.C.S.*, Richard Grocott-Mason,
M.R.C.P., M.D.*, Hassan Elwidaa, M.R.C.P.* and Rashid Mazhar, F.R.C.S.*
London, England
Discussant: Mark F. O'Brien, M.D., Brisbane, Australia
Homografts
offer many advantages over prosthetic valves, however, homograft durability
varies considerably.
From 1969
through 1993, 618 patients aged 15-84 (mean 51) years underwent their first AYR
with an aortic homograft. Concomitant surgery included root tailoring (N = 64),
replacement of the ascending aorta (N = 56), coronary bypass grafting (N = 87).
Homograft implantation was done using a freehand' subcoronary technique (N =
551) or total root replacement (N = 67). The homografts were antibiotic
sterilized (N = 479), cryo-preserved (N=12), or homovitals' (nutrient medium,
inserted within 72 h; N = 127). Maximum follow-up was 27.1 (mean 10.1) years.
Thirty-day
mortality was 5.0% and 10- and 20-year crude survivals ± standard error (SE) 67
± 2% and 35 ± 3%, respectively. Ten- and 20-year complication freedoms ± SE
included: endocarditis 93 ± 1% and 89 ± 2%, respectively; primary tissue
failure, 62 ± 3% and 18 ±3%, respectively; and re-do AYR, 81 ± 2% and 35 ± 4%,
respectively. Multivariate COX analyses identified several valve and procedure
related determinants which included: rising homograft donor age and antibiotic
sterilized/cryopreserved homograft for mortality; donor > 10 years older than
patient for endocarditis; rising donor minus patient age, rising implantation
(from harvest to AYR) time, and donor age > 65 years for tissue failure; and
rising donor minus patients age, young patient age, rising implantation time,
subcoronary implantation, and aortic root tailoring for re-do AYR. Estimated
10- and 20-year freedoms from tissue failure for a 60-year-old patient with a
homovital' and no other risk factors were 88% and 52%, respectively, for a
donor age of 30 years and 72% and 21%, respectively, for a donor of 60 years;
the freedoms for a 30-year-old patient were 78% and 31%, respectively, for a
30-year-old donor and 56% and 7%, respectively, for a 60-year-old donor.
Beneficial influences of a homovital' were largely covered by short harvest
time (0 for homografts from brain dead organ donors or heart transplant
recipients) and short implantation time.
It is
concluded that primary homograft AYR can give acceptable results for up to 25
years and that the late results can be improved by the use of a homovital'
valve, by matching patient and donor age, and by more liberal use of a free
root replacement with re-implantation of the coronary arteries rather than
tailoring the root to accomodate a subcoronary implantation.
*By invitation
9:40 a.m. EVARTS A. GRAHAM MEMORIAL
TRAVELING FELLOW PRESENTATION
Jun Wang, M.D. Beijing, People's
Republic of China
9:45 a.m. INTERMISSION - VISIT EXHIBITS
MONDAY, MAY 4, 1998
10:30 a.m. PLENARY SCIENTIFIC SESSION
Ballroom, Hynes Convention Center
Moderators: Lawrence H. Cohn, M.D.
James L. Cox, M.D.
5. THE FIRST GENERATION OF
ENDOVASCULAR STENT-GRAFTS FOR DESCENDING THORACIC ANEURYSMS.
D. Craig Miller, M.D., R. Scott Mitchell, M.D.*,
James I. Fann, M.D.* and Michael D. Dake, M.D.*
Stanford, California
Discussant: Randall B. Griepp,
M.D, New York, New York
From July 1992 to October 1997,
109 patients (mean age 68 years [range 34-89 years]) underwent endovascular
stent-grafting of descending thoracic aortic disorders using a custom
fabricated, self-expanding device. Follow-up was 100% complete, and averaged 21
months. Eighty-five (78%) patients had atherosclerotic aneurysms, 8 were due to
aortic dissection, 8 post-traumatic, 5 anastomotic, 2 mycotic (healed), and 1
was degenerative. Twelve patients presented with aortic rupture. Fourteen (13%)
patients had undergone one or more previous thoracic aortic surgical
procedures. Over one-half of patients had been judged not to be
reasonable candidates for "open" conventional surgical repair. Access was from
the femoral artery in 60% of patients, abdominal aorta in 31%, iliac artery in
7%, and the aortic arch in 2%. Twenty-four patients underwent simultaneous
abdominal aortic aneurysm repair. Complete thrombosis of the aneurysm was
achieved in 104 (95%) patients (14 required post-procedure stent/graft
extensions or coil embolization) prior to discharge. One patient died
intraoperatively of aneursym perforation. Early mortality rate was 8 ± 3% (±
70% CL). The only multivariate independent risk factor for early death was
smaller aortic diameter. Early complications included paraplegia in 4%, stroke
in 3%, iliac artery avulsion in 2%, proximal aortic dissection in 2%,
myocardial infarction in 1%, colon ischemia in 1%, and renal failure in 1%.
Acturial survival estimates at 6 months, 1 year, and 5 years were 88%, 84%, and
77 ± 5% (± 1 SE), respectively. According to the intent to treat principle,
"Treatment Failure" (conservatively defined as all late sudden, unexplained
deaths, deaths due to aneurysm rupture, need for subsequent stent-grafting or
operation, and endoleak) occurred in 18 patients (or 16%). Actuarial estimates
of freedom from Treatment Failure at 1 and 5 years were 84% and 71 ± 8%,
respectively. Emergency stent-grafting was the only independent risk factor for
Treatment Failure. Three (3%) patients subsequently required definitive (open)
surgical repair after 4, 43, and 61 months.
Conclusions: This 5 year
clinical trial employing a relatively primitive stent/graft device indicates
that endovascular descending thoracic aortic stent-grafting is feasible with
acceptable medium-term results, which are comparable to the outcome after open
operation; however, additional follow-up is still required to assess fully the
long-term efficacy of this technique. The more refined, commercially-developed
devices used today offer less traumatic and more precise stent/graft
deployment; these major technical advantages, coupled with the important
lessons we have learned over time, should be associated with even more salutary
long-term clinical results in the future.
*By invitation
6. TWO INTERNAL THORACIC ARTERY GRAFTS
ARE BETTER THAN ONE.
Bruce W. Lytle, M.D., John H. Arnold, M.D.*, Floyd
D. Loop, M.D., Penny Whiteman, M.S.*, Robert W. Stewart, M.D., Patrick M.
McCarthy, M.D. and Delos M. Cosgrove, M.D.
Cleveland, Ohio
Discussant: Hendrick B. Barnes,
M.D., St. Louis, Missouri
Do bilateral ITA (BITA)
grafts produce better outcomes than a single ITA graft (SITA)? To examine this
issue for patients undergoing primary coronary artery bypass grafting, we
reviewed the surgical strategies and outcomes for 2015 consecutive patients
receiving BITA grafting with or without additional vein grafts and, for
comparison, 8059 patients receiving SITA grafts and at least one vein graft. To
achieve long follow-up intervals, patients were selected for review who
underwent operation from 1971 through 1989. Treatment selection was not
randomized and the BITA group had a lower mean age, included more men, fewer
patients with diabetes, and more patients with triple vessel disease (all p
< 0.01). The in-hospital mortality rate was 0.7% for both groups. Late
follow-up (mean postoperative interval 10.3 years after BITA, 304 BITA patients
with > 12 year follow-up) documented 51 reoperations and 177 percutaneous
interventions (PTCA) after BITA grafting. Survival for the BITA group was 94%,
84%, and 67% and for the SITA group 91%, 79% and 64% at 5, 10 and 15
postoperative years, respectively (p < 0.001). Cox regression analyses were
used to test patient and treatment related variables in multi-variate models
for their associations with late outcomes and to establish the increases in
relative risks associated with those variables. The table shows tests of
significance and the adjusted risk ratios (p value [relative risk ratio]) for
the patients in the SITA group relative to the BITA patients according to age
group and outcomes. For all age groups, the risks of death and reoperation were
higher for patients in the SITA group, except for the risk of death for patients
< 50 years old.
|
|
Late Death
|
Reoperation
|
Late Death
or Reoperation
|
Late
Death, Reoperation, or PTCA
|
|
All
patients
|
<0.001 (1.31)
|
<0.001 (3.74)
|
<0.001 (1.61)
|
<0.001 (1.51)
|
|
< 50
years
|
N/S (1.05)
|
<0.001 (6.78)
|
<0.001 (1.77)
|
<0.001 (1.55)
|
|
50-60
years
|
0.002 (1.41)
|
<0.001 (3.58)
|
<0.001 (1.77)
|
<0.001 (1.56)
|
|
> 60
years
|
<0.001 (1.36)
|
0.001 (2.33)
|
<0.001 (1.44)
|
<0.001 (1.44)
|
Neither total arterial revascularization nor the specific
vessels grafted with BITA improved results when compared to the general strategy
of BITA grafting.
These data suggest that BITA grafting improved the survival
rate over that for
SITA grafting in all age groups except for those < 50
years old. Futhermore, they provide strong evidence that BITA grafting
substantially decreases the risk of reoperation for all age groups.
11:15 a.m. PRESIDENTIAL ADDRESS
"...The First Living and the
Last Dying"
Floyd D. Loop, M.D., Cleveland,
Ohio
12:00 p.m. ADJOURN FOR LUNCH - VISIT EXHIBITS
*By invitation