1:30 pm PLENARY SESSION
Auditorium, Hynes Convention
Center
Moderators: Aldo R. Castaneda, M.D.
John A. Waldhausen, M.D.
6. LATE HEMODYNAMIC RESULTS FOLLOWING
LEFT VENTRICULAR PATCH REPAIR ASSOCIATED WITH CORONARY GRAFTING IN PATIENTS
WITH POST-INFARCTION AKINETIC OR DYSKINETIC LEFT VENTRICULAR ANEURYSM
Vincent Dor, M.D., Michel
Sabatier, M.D.*, Francoise Montiglio, M.D.*, Anna Toso, M.D.*, Mauro Maioli,
M.D.* and Marisa Di Donate, M.D.*
Monte-Carlo, Monaco and
Florence, Italy
Aim of the
study: To evaluate hemodynamic, clinical and electrophysio-logic data one
year after intervention of left ventricular patch repair (LVR) and associated
coronary revascularization in patients (pts) with postinfarction akinetic and
dyskinetic LV aneurysm.
Patients: Among
580 pts who underwent this type of surgery since 1984, we report the results
obtained in 141 pts (132 men and 9 women, mean age 58±8 yrs) who accepted to be
controlled 1 year postoperatively with the same protocol. All these pts had
right and left heart catheterization, ventricular and coronary angiography,
programmed ventricular stimulation (PVS) unless contraindicated, before, one
month and one year after surgery. Site of the aneurysm was anterior in 135 and
posterior in 6. Mean delay from first infarction was 36 months (range 1-198).
Fifty-three pts had one vessel (V), 55 two V and 33 three V disease. Eleven pts
were in NYHA class I, 51 in class II, 54 in class III, and 25 in class IV.
Clinical ventricular arrhythmias (VA) were present in 35 pts (25%) and ventricular
tachycardia was inducible in 43/94 pts who underwent preop PVS (46%).
Indications for surgery were a combination of cardiac insufficiency, angina and
VA in the majority of pts. Twenty-one pts were operated in emergency.
Results: All
pts had LVR by endoventricular patch plasty with synthetic or autologous patch.
Associated procedures included subtotal endocardectomy and cryotherapy in pts
with clinical or inducible VT; ventricular septal defect closure in two pts;
mitral valve replacement in two and repair in six pts; aortic valve replacement
in one pt and repair in another patient. One hundred thirty-five pts (96%) had
associated myocardial revascularization (IV in 49 pts, 2 V in 57, 3 V in 27 and
4 V grafts in 2). Internal mammary artery was implanted in 120 pts, almost
always on LAD, and was found to be patent after one year in 113 (94%). The mean
number of by-pass was 1.89±.86. Mean cardiopulmonary by-pass time was 110±33
min. Twenty-two pts required intraaortic balloon pump preoperatively (10 elective
and 11 in emergency). Perioperative complications were cardiac insufficiency
requiring inotropic drugs in 20 pts; mechanical assistance in 8 pts; renal
failure in 6 pts; bleeding requiring blood transfusion in 11 pts; conduction
disturbances requiring temporary pacing in 30 pts.
After 1 year from surgery
mean EF significantly increased (from 35±13 to 46±12%, p<.0001); end
diastolic and end systolic volume index significantly decreased (from 116±43 to
96±29 and from 76±41 to 54±26 ml/m2, respectively p<.001). Table reports
early and late results on the basis of basal value in EF
|
|
EF<30%
|
30
|
EF>40%
|
|
Base
|
22±5
|
37±2
|
50±7
|
|
Early postop
|
42±10
|
49±11
|
57±8
|
|
Late postop
|
41±11
|
44±11
|
52±12
|
All
data are significant at two way variance analysis.
Spontaneous VT
were significantly reduced (only two pts had documented clinical VTs during 1
year period); VT was inducible in 8/117 pts who underwent late PVS (7%)
p<.001. One out of the 8 pts was not inducible before surgery; 76 pts were
in NYHA class I; 50 pts in NYHA II; 11 pts in NYHA III and 4 in NYHA IV. Angina
was still present in 8 pts (6%) while 102 pts (72%) complained of angina before
surgery.
Conclusions:
Our results demonstrate that LV aneurysm patch repair associated with
complete coronary revascularization and with subtotal endocardectomy and
cryotherapy (when indicated), induces: 1) a long-term significant improvement
in LV pump function especially in pts with a low basal EF; 2) a significant
improvement in clinical status; and 3) a significant reduction of clinical and
inducible ventricular arrhythmias.
*By invitation
7. REDUCTION OF PERIOPERATIVE
NEUROLOGICAL MORBIDITY IN CORONARY BYPASS SURGERY: A RANDOMIZED TRIAL OF HIGH
VERSUS LOW INTRAOPERATIVE BLOOD PRESSURE MANAGEMENT
Jeffrey P. Gold, M.D, Mary E.
Charlson, M..D.*, Karl H. Krieger, M.D., Pamela Williams-Russo, M.D.*, Stephen
J. Thomas, M.D.*, Ted P. Szatrowski, M.D., Denise Barbut, M.D.*, Janey
Peterson, R.N.*, Paul Pirraglia, M.S.* and O. Wayne Isom, M.D.
New York, New York
Optimal management of the
mean arterial blood pressure (MAP) on cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) during
coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) remains controversial. Patients (248)
undergoing elective multivessel coronary artery bypass grafting were randomized
preoperatively to a low (50-60 mmHg) or high (80-100mmHg) MAP group. All
patients were evaluated preoperatively with a cardiac, neurologic, cognitive,
and functional test battery which was repeated one week and six months
postoperatively. Intraoperative transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) studies
complemented standard monitoring and management. CPB temperatures and flow were
fixed, and MAP was adjusted with a standardized regimen of vasoactive drugs.
The study groups did not
differ with respect to age, gender, race, cardiac history, extent of coronary
artery disease, LV-EF, as well as all preoperative aspects of the neurological,
psychometric, functional, and cognitive test batteries. The mean age was 66
years; 80% were male. Preoperatively the mean LV-EF was 48%, and 53% had a
previous MI. There were no difference in the operative mortality (1.6%),
crossclamp time (41"), pump time (8"), number of grafts (3.1), or in
post-operative bleeding. Postoperative cardiopulmonary events were defined as
shock, MI, pulmonary edema, and ARDS. Neurologic events were defined as
persistent (>24 hr) deficits correllated with CT scan findings (paresis,
plegia, aphasia, central sensory, hemianppsia & cortical blindness).
Cognitive deterioration was defined as a clinically important decline on three
of twelve neuropsychiatric tests, and a functional deterioration as a five
point decline in the SF-36 score.
Patients with MAP
maintained within the high pressure range had fewer neurological complications
(1.6% vs 6.4%, p<0.001) than their low MAP counterparts (independent of
preoperative risk factors and TEE assessed degree of aortic ASVD). In patients
with advanced aortic ASVD on TEE (16%), the perioperative CVA rate was 30% in
the low MAP group, compared to 10% in the high MAP group (p<0.001). There
were no significant differences in the incidence of long term cognitive (11.4%
vs. 12.3%) or functional (13.7% vs. 10.5%) changes. These findings indicated
that patients with mean arterial pressure on CPB maintained at a higher range
(presumably closer to their auto-regulatory range ) have a substantial
reduction in perioperative neurological morbidity following elective CABG when
compared to patients with conventional intraoperative pressure management.
*By invitation
8. REPAIR OF LONG SEGMENT TRACHEAL
STENOSIS IN INFANCY
Robert D.B. Jaquiss, M.D.*, Rodney M. Lusk, M.D.*,
Thomas L. Spray, M.D. and Charles B. Huddleston, M.D.*
St. Louis, Missouri
Congenital long
segment stenosis of the trachea (LSTS) presents a considerable surgical
challenge because of the difficulty in providing distal ventilation during the
repair and because the optimal type of repair is not clearly defined. This
report summarizes our experience with an anterior rib cartilage tracheoplasty
using cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) to avoid direct intubation of the distal
airway. Six patients underwent repair of LSTS between September 1987 and the
present. The median age was 14 weeks (range = 1 to 58 weeks) and the mean
weight was 4.8 kg (range = 2.9 to 9.9 kg). All patients had involvement of at
least 70% of the tracheal length, typically from the thoracic inlet to the
carina with complete cartilaginous rings over much of the stenotic segment. Two
patients also had involvement of one or both mainstem bronchi. Associated
anomalies were present in two patients (tetralogy of Fallot in one and patent
ductus arteriosus in one). In all patients a median sternotomy was employed and
the anterior surface of the trachea was exposed from the thoracic inlet to the
carina. After identification of the upper extent of the stenosis by rigid
bronchoscopy, a vertical incision was made in the anterior trachea through the
entire stenotic segment. A previously harvested segment of rib cartilage, with
intact perichondrium, was then fashioned to correspond to the long tracheotomy
and sewn in place as an augmentation patch with the perichondrium facing the
lumen. In order to avoid distal airway intubation, all procedures were
performed on CPB with a mean bypass duration of 110 minutes (range = 54 to 175
minutes). Mechanical ventilation was required postoperatively for a median of
11 days (range = 7 to 81 days), and the median postoperative hospital stay was
17 days (range = 12 to 180 days). There were no operative deaths and all
patients are long term survivors. Complications include the need for ECMO
support to treat unexplained ventricular dysfunction in one patient and graft
dehiscence requiring re-exploration and placement of additional sutures in
another. The patient who developed graft dehiscence has required several
bronchoscopies for removal of granulation tissue. All other patients are
asymptomatic without evidence of airway obstruction and have normal growth and
development with a mean follow-up of 4.4 years (range = 1 month to 7.3 years).
We conclude that rib cartilage tracheoplasty for LSTS provides excellent
results in short and intermediate follow-up. In addition, the use of CPB allows
an unobstructed view of the tiny infant airway, and thus permits a precise
repair.
*By invitation
9. RECURRENCE OF OBLITERATIVE
BRONCHIOLITIS AND DETERMINANTS OF OUTCOME IN 139 PULMONARY RETRANSPLANT
RECIPIENTS.
Richard J. Novick M.D.,
Hans-Joachim Schafers, M.D.*, Larry W. Stitt, M.Sc.*, Walter Kleptko, M.D.*,
Bernard Andr6assian, M.D.*, Jean-Pierre Duchatelle, M.D.*, Robert L. Hardesty,
M.D., Adaani E. Frost, M.D.*, and G. Alexander Patterson, M.D.
London, Ontario, Canada,
Hannover, Germany, Vienna, Austria, Paris, France, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania,
Houston, Texas and St. Louis, Missouri
An
international series of pulmonary retransplantation (retx) was updated in order
to identify the determinants of outcome and the prevalence and recurrence rate
of obliterative bronchiolitis (OB) postoperatively. The study cohort included
139 patients who underwent retx in 34 institutions in North America and Europe
from 1985 to 1994. Eighty patients were retransplanted for OB, 34 for acute
graft failure, 13 for intractable airway problems, 8 for acute rejection and 4
for other indications. Survivors were followed for a mean of 706 ± 67 days,
with 48 patients alive at 1 year, 30 at 2 years and 16 at 3 years after retx. Follow-up
was 100% complete. Actuarial survival was 65 ± 4% at one month, 45 ±
4% at 1 year, 38 ± 5% at 2 years and 36 ± 5% at 3 years; nonetheless, of 90 day
postoperative survivors, 65 ± 6% were alive 3 years after retx. Most deaths
were caused by infection (48/85, 56%), followed by acute failure of the second
graft (22%), recurrent OB (14%), an airway complication (4%) or other causes
(4%). Life table and univariate Cox analysis of 18 variables revealed that more
recent year of retransplantation (p = 0.009), ABO blood group identity (p =
0.01), absence of a donor-recipient cytomegalovirus mismatch (p = 0.04) and
being ambulatory immediately prior to retx (p = 0.04) were associated with
survival. There was a trend toward improved outcome (p = 0.5610) in centers
with experience in at least 5 pulmonary retx procedures. On multivariate Cox
analysis, being ambulatory prior to retx was the most significant predictor of
survival (p = 0.008).
Complete pulmonary
function test results were obtained yearly from every survivor of retx.
Bronchiolitis Obliterans Syndrome (BOS) stages were assigned according to
standard criteria, based on absolute FEV] values (J Heart Lung Transplant 1993;
12:713-6). The percentage of retx patients in each BOS stage is shown in the
table:
|
Postop Interval
|
No. of Patients
|
Stage 0
|
Stage 1
|
Stage 2
|
Stage 3
|
|
1 year
|
48
|
79%
|
4%
|
6%
|
11%
|
|
2 years
|
30
|
63%
|
10%
|
7%
|
20%
|
|
3 years
|
16
|
69%
|
6%
|
0%
|
25%
|
Absolute FEV] values decreased by
6 ± 4% at 1 year and 18 ± 5% at 2 years from postoperative baseline values
(p=0.07, year 2 versus year 1). There were no significant differences in BOS
stages or the rate of FEVj decrease between patients reoperated for OB versus
other conditions or between single or double lung retx patients. We conclude
that survival after pulmonary retx is improving with increasing experience.
Optimal results can be obtained in patients who are ambulatory prior to retx
and receive an ABO-identical graft. OB does not appear to recur in a
more accelerated manner after retx. As long as early mortality due to infection
can be minimized, pulmonary retx appears to offer a reasonable option in highly
selected patients.
2:50 pm INTERMISSION - VISIT EXHIBITS
*By invitation
3:30 pm PLENARY SESSION
Auditorium, Hynes Convention Center
Moderators: Aldo R. Castaneda, M.D.
John A. Waldhausen, M.D.
10. COMBINED LUNG AND LIVER
TRANSPLANTATION IN CYSTIC FIBROSIS PATIENTS. A 4.5 YEAR EXPERIENCE
Jean-Paul A. Couetil, M.D.*,
Didier Houssin, M.D.*, Patrick Chevalier, M.D.*, Bertrand Dousset, M.D.*,
Didier F. Loulmet, M.D.*, Olivier Soubrane, M.D.*, Romain J. Guillemain, M.D.*,
Catherine I. Amrein, M.D.*, Alain Guinvarch, M.D.* and Alain F. Carpentier,
M.D., Ph.D.
Paris, France
Cystic fibrosis
(CF) patients (pts) with end stage respiratory failure and associated liver
cirrhosis have been considered as poor candidates for lung transplantation
because of high morbidity and mortality due to hepatic insufficiency following
the operation. Since June 1990 our policy has been to combine lung or
heart-lung and liver transplantation in this group of pts. Among the 15 pts
enrolled in the program, 5 died while awaiting transplantation and 10 underwent
one of the following procedures: heart-lung-liver (n=5), En bloc
double-lung-liver (n=1), sequential double-lung-liver (n=3), bilateral lobar
lung from a split left lung and reduced liver (n=1). The latter was performed
because of a large size discrepancy between donor and recipient. All pts were infected
with persistent Pseudomonas, and 2 had in addition Aspergillus species.
Pre-operative forced vital capacity and forced expiratory volume/sec were 35 ±
8% and 30 ± 5% of predicted values. All pts were on continuous oxygen and all
suffered from severe cirrhosis with portal hypertension. Four had a history of
esophageal variceal bleeding and two had had previous portosystemic shunts.
Selection of donor organs was based on established criteria for lung and liver
transplantation. The operation was performed as a two-stage procedure, the
intra-thoracic stage being completed before commencing the abdominal stage. Results:
2 pts died in the post-operative period, one from primary liver failure (at
10 days), the second from pulmonary edema (at 21 days). Other complications
included tracheal stenosis (n=1), biliary stenosis (n=3) and severe ascites
(n=3). All were successfully treated. Four pts developed established diabetes
post-operatively. Obliterative bronchiolitis (OB) developed in 2 pts at one
year and 1 pt at two years. Of those, 2 pts were successfully treated with
FK506. The other pt who was not treated with FK.506 continued to deteriorate
and required heart-lung transplantation at 38 months but eventually died from
bleeding. Estimated actuarial survival is 68.6 ± 12% at 3 years which is
comparable to survival achieved for lung transplantation alone in CF pts in our
unit. Conclusion: This series, the largest reported, demonstrates
that in CF patients suffering from chronic respiratory failure with advanced
cirrhosis, and thus having minimal life expectancy, lung transplantation
combined with liver transplantation can be performed with satisfactory outcome.
*By invitation
11. PHASE I TRIAL OF FK506 IN CLINICAL
HEART TRANSPLANTATION: IMMEDIATE TERM RESULTS
Si M. Pham, M.D.*, Robert L.
Kormos, M.D., Brack G. Hattler, M.D.*, Athabassios C. Tsamandas, M.D.*, Anthony
J. Demetris, M.D.*, Frederick J. Fricker, M.D.*, Thomas E. Starzl, M.D.* and
Hartley P. Griffith, M.D. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
FK506, a macrolide
antibiotic and a potent T-cell suppressor, recently received FDA approval for
treatment of liver recipients. A phase I trial of FK506 in clinical heart
transplantation was initiated at our center in 1989. The present study reports
the intermediate term results of this trial.
Between 01/01/89 and
10/01/94, 136 primary heart recipients (age=0-65 years) received
FK506/steroids/azathioprine regimen (FK), while 121 others were treated with
cyclosporine-based immunosuppression (CBIS) consisting of triple drugs (cyclosporine
A, azathioprine, steroids) and lympholytic induction with either rabbit
antithymocyte globulin (RATG) or OKT3. The actuarial 1-, 2-, and 4-year
survival for the FK and CBIS groups were 86%, 83% and 77%, and 93%, 89% and
73%, respectively (p=NS). Renal toxicity was the major side effect of both
drugs. Mean serum creatinine values at 1 year were slightly higher for FK506
recipients (FK=2.2±1.2 vs CBIS=1.8±0.6; p=0.06). This probably reflected our
learning curve for the use of FK506. By two years, the difference in creatinine
disappeared (FK506=2.2±0.9 vs CBIS=2.1±0.9; p=0.5). There was a higher rate of
intractable rejection (refractory to steroid bolus and RATG or OKT3) in the
CBIS group (p<0.05). Fourteen CBIS patients had intractable rejection; all
resolved with FK506 rescue. Two FK patients had intractable rejection requiring
total lymphoid irradiation and methotrexate rescue. Endomyocardial specimens of
132 adult patients (FK=52, CBIS=50) were available for histopathological
analysis. There was a trend toward a greater incidence of ISHLT Grade 2 or
higher rejections (57% vs 40%, p=0.07) during the first 30 days in the FK506
arm. In contrast, there was a trend toward more Quilty lesion (27% vs 15%,
p<0.27) and endocardia! fibrosis in the one-year biopsies of the CBIS
recipients. The intermediate term outcome of cardiac recipients under FK506
compares favorably with those under the cyclosporine-based protocol plus
lympholytic induction. FK506 is an effective rescue agent for intractable
rejection under conventional immunosuppression.
*By invitation
12. COMPARATIVE STUDY OF CONVENTIONAL AND
"TOTAL" (WITH CAVAL ANASTOMOSIS) ORTHOTOPIC HEART TRANSPLANTATION
Dominique R. Metras, M.D.,
Bernard Kreitmann, M.D.*, Alberto Riberi, M.D.*, Gilbert Habib, M.D.*, Pierre
Ambrosi, M.D.* and Adrienne Pannetier, M.D.*
Marseille, France
Conventional orthotopic
heart transplantation (OHT) has been reported to modify size and geometry of
both atria and to cause mitral and tricuspid regurgitation affecting
ventricular filling. Since 1992 we have systematically performed a modified
technique of OHT with extensive resection of the recipient's heart, anastomosis
of a small peri-venous cuff of left atrium and of both venae cavae. Our total
experience includes 120 OHT, with 70 conventional technique (group I) and 50
modified technique (group II). Both groups were similar in age, pre-transplant
characteristics, post-operative management including immunosuppression, and
routine antithrombotic therapy (low molecular weight heparin followed by
anti-agregant). The recipient aortic cross clamping time (i.e., time of heart
excision and heart implantation) was longer in Group II (87 ± 19 mn vs 65 ± 15
mn; p<0.001). No haemorrhagic complication or surgical problems (such as
caval thrombosis and/or stenosis) imputable to the technique were noted.
Peri-operative and subsequent mortality were similar in both groups. Five
patients in Group I presented a documented systemic embolism one month to five
years after OHT, two of them with neurologic sequelae. No thromboembolic
episode occurred in Group II.
Two comparable groups of
25 patients were studied at 6 months post-transplant (Group A after
conventional OHT; Group B after modified OHT) with EKG, 24 hours EK.G Holter
examination, and trans-thoracic and oesophagial echodoppler. A higher number of
EKG anomalies, a significant increase in atrial size, a significantly higher
proportion of mitral and tricuspid insufficiencies and a significantly higher
coefficient of variation of the E/A ratio (parameter of left ventricular
filling) were noted in Group A. Spontaneous echocontrast and atrial thrombi
were present in the left atrium of several patients of Group A (50% and 20%,
respectively) and never noted in Group B. We conclude that this modification of
OHT lengthening surgery by about 20 mn achieves a closer to normal cardiac
anatomy and geometry. Less anomalies of the cardiac function were found, the
long term significance of which are yet unknown. A lower number of
echocardiographic features of left atrial thrombosis and an absence of systemic
embolism prompt us to think there is a definite advantage in this technically
simple approach.
*By invitation
13. MEDIASTINAL LYMPH NODE STAGING OF
NON-SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER: A PROSPECTIVE COMPARISON OF COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY AND
POSITRON EMISSION TOMOGRAPHY
Walter J. Scott, M.D.*, Lisa S.
Gobar, M.D.*, John D. Terry, M.D.*, John J. Sunderland, Ph.D.*, Naresh A,
Dewan, M.D.* and Jeffrey T. Sugimoto, M.D.*
Omaha, Nebraska
Sponsored by: Alex G. Little, Las Vegas, Nevada
We prospectively compared
the abilities of positron emission tomography (PET) and computed tomography
(CT) to detect lymph node metastases (N2 or N3) in patients with non-small cell
lung cancer (NSCLC). PET detects increased rates of glucose uptake,
characteristic of malignant cells, by measuring the uptake of a
positron-emitting glucose analogue administered intravenously.
Patients had known or
suspected NSCLC and were candidates for surgical staging. Patients with
peripheral, <2 cm tumors and a normal mediastinum were ineligible. All
patients underwent CT, PET, and surgical staging. The American Thoracic Society
lymph node map was used. CT and PET scans were read by separate radiologists
blinded to surgical staging results. Lymph nodes were positive by CT if >
1.0 cm in short-axis diameter. The CT, but not the interpretation, was
available to the radiologist reading the PET to help localize areas of uptake.
Standardized uptake values (SUVs) were recorded from areas on PET corresponding
to those that were biopsied. Node regions with an SUV >4.2 were called
positive.
All patients had NSCLC
and all primary tumors were detected by PET. A total of 75 lymph node stations
(2.8 per patient) were analyzed in 27 patients. Patients underwent
mediastinoscopy (9), thoracotomy (19), thoracoscopy (1), and scalene node
biopsy (2). N2/N3 metastases were present in 10/75 stations (13.3%), and 9/27
patients (33.3%). CT incorrectly staged 3 patients as positive and 3 as
negative for mediastinal metastases. CT sensitivity and specificity were 67%
and 83%, respectively. PET correctly staged the mediastinum in all 27 patients,
for a sensitivity and specificity of 100%. When analyzed by individual node
station, there were 4 false positives and 4 false negatives by CT (sensitivity
= 60%, specificity = 93%, positive predictive value = 60%). PET mislabeled one
negative node station as positive (100% sensitive, 98% specific, positive
predictive value 91%). The stage of the patient was unchanged. The differences
between CT and PET were significant when the data were analyzed using the
McNemar test (one-sided) for both individual lymph node stations (p=0.039) and
for patients (p=0.031). We conclude that PET supplemented by CT is more
accurate than CT in detecting mediastinal lymph node metastases in patients
with non-small cell lung cancer.
*By invitation
14. SURFACE-BOUND HEPARIN FAILS TO REDUCE
THROMBIN FORMATION DURING CLINICAL CARDIOPULMONARY BYPASS
Robert C. Gorman, M.D.*,
Nicholas P. Ziats, Ph.D.*, Nicolas Gikakis, B.S.*, Ling Sun, Ph.D.*, Mohammed
M.H. Khan, M.D., Ph.D.*, Nina Stenach, B.A.*, Suneeti Sapatnekar, M.D.*, Matt
L. Robertson*, Stefan Niewiarowski, M.D., Ph.D.*, Robert W. Colman, M.D.*, A.
Koneti Rao, M.D.*, James L. Anderson, M.D., Ph.D.* and L. Henry Edmunds, Jr.,
M.D.
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
The hypothesis
that heparin-coated perfusion circuits reduce thrombin formation, fibrinolysis
and platelet, complement and neutrophil activation was tested in 20
consecutive, randomized adults who had cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). Medtronic,
Inc. provided 20 identical perfusion systems, but in 10 all blood contacting
surfaces were coated with partially degraded heparin (Carmeda process). All
patients received 3 mgm/kg heparin; activated clotting times were maintained over
400 seconds; CPB lasted 36 to 244 min.
Blood samples
for platelet count: platelet response to ADP; plasma beta thromboglobulin
(BTG); Complement 3b; neutrophil elastase; fibrinopeptide A (FPA); prothrombin
fragment, F1.2; thrombin-antithrombin III complex (TAT); and D-dimer were
obtained after heparin, 5 and 30 min after starting CPB, within 5 min after CPB
and 15 min after protamine. After CPB, tubing segments were analyzed for
surface adsorbed antithrombin III (At-IH), fibrinogen, Factor XII, and von Willebrand
factor by radioimmunoassay (RIA) and by immunogold labeling.
Heparin-coated
circuits significantly (p<0.05) reduced platelet adhesion during CPB, but
did not alter platelet sensitivity to ADP nor reduce the increase in plasma
BTG, C3b or neutrophil elastase. There were no significant differences between
groups at any time for FPA, F1.2, TAT, or D-dimer. In both groups F1.2 and TAT
increased progressively and significantly during CPB and after protamine. After
CPB, F1.2=5.8 nmol/L, control; 5.7 nmol/L, Carmeda; TAT=52.1 pmol/L, control;
51.6 pmol/L, Carmeda. FPA increased significantly after protamine in both
groups (30.1 ng/ml, control, 28.7 ng/ml, Carmeda). D-dimer increased
significantly during CPB, but not after protamine. RIA showed a significant
increase in surface adsorbed At-III on coated circuits, but no significant
differences between groups for the other proteins.
We conclude
that heparin-coated circuits fail to reduce the significant increases in all
markers of thrombin and fibrin formation during CPB and also fail to attenuate
activation of complement, platelets and neutrophils. For clinical CPB these
hematologic and biochemical data indicate that heparin-coated circuits are not
advantageous and that they should not be used with reduced systemic doses of
heparin except under extraordinary circumstances.
*By invitation