WEDNESDAY MORNING, April 30, 1986
8:30 a.m. SCIENTIFIC SESSION - Grand
Ballroom
32. Fontan Type Operation for Complex Lesions:
Surgical Considerations to Improve Survival
SERAFIN Y. DELEON*,
MICHEL N. ILBAWI*,
FAROUK S. IDRISS,
ALEXANDER J. MUSTER*,
SAMUEL S. GIDDING*,
TERESA E. BERRY*
and MILTON H. PAUL*
Chicago, Illinois
Twenty-two of
44 patients who underwent the Fontan type operation (FO) had complex lesions
other than tricuspid atresia with ventriculo-arterial concordance. Their age
ranged from 2 to 20 years. Nine had single ventricle, 5 had tricuspid atresia
with transposition, and 8 had various other lesions. Two groups were
identified. Group I had pulmonic stenosis with (N = 6) and without N = 9)
previous systemic-pulmonary artery shunt. Group II (N = 7) had pulmonary artery
banding. Three patients had significant subaortic stenosis. Twenty-six
palliative operations, including 6 preliminary Glenn shunts, were performed
prior to the FO. The mean pulmonary artery pressure and vascular resistance ranged
from 10 to 26 torr and .5 to 2.9 u.M2 respectively. Direct RA-to-PA
anastomosis was carried out in 18 patients (7 with valve) and valved conduits
were used in 4 patients. Eleven patients had right atrioventricular (A-V) valve
patch closure (3 running, 8 interrupted suture technique).
In Group I, 40% developed significant pleural
and/or pericardial effusion compared with 100% in Group II (p<.02) and the
average length of hospital stay was 20 days and 45 days respectively.
Significant patch disruption occurred in 3 patients, 2 of whom had the running
suture technique. Two patients developed late conduit occlusion in whom the
Glenn shunt was lifesaving. Four patients (3 from Group II and all with
subaortic stenosis) required Fontan takedown (FT) for persistent low cardiac
output (PLCO), 2 of whom died (2/22, 9%). None of the patients with established
Glenn shunt required FT. Twenty patients including the 2 patients who survived
FT were followed over 3.5 years (range 2 months to 6 years) and did well except
for 2 late deaths (10%, 4 months, and 4 years later). We believe that early FT
in patients with PLCO, interrupted suture technique for A-V valve closure, and
a preliminary Glenn shunt in patients with pulmonary artery banding and/or
subaortic stenosis can further improve the results with the Fontan operation
for complex lesions.
*By Invitation
8:40 a.m.
33. Comparison of Atriopulmonary Versus
Atrioventricular Connections for Repair of Tricuspid Atresia
CHUEN N. LEE*,
HARTZELL V. SCHAFF*,
GORDON K. DANIELSON,
FRANCISCO J. PUGA
and DAVID J.
DRISCOLL*
Rochester, Minnesota
Physiologic repair as described by Kreutzer and
Fontan has provided excellent palliation for many children with tricuspid valve
atresia. This study compares the early and late results of two variations of
physiologic repair of tricuspid atresia: (1) direct atriopulmonary (AP)
connection without interposed valves and (2) atrioventricular (AV) connection
leaving the native pulmonary valve in place and utilizing the pumping capacity
of the residual right ventricle. From January 1979 through March 1984, 50 pts
had AP connection and 25 pts had AV connection during physiologic repair.
Preoperative characteristics including age, severity of disability, and
presence of cardiomegaly were similar. Pts with AP connection had fewer Glenn
shunts (14% vs 44%, p<0.004) and a higher incidence of previous Waterston
shunts (42% vs 16%, p<0.024) than pts with AV connection. Operative results
in the two pt groups were similar, including cardio-pulmonary bypass time,
aortic cross-clamp time, postoperative morbidity, and operative risk (30-day
mortality 6% for AP connections vs 8% for AV connections). The only significant
difference postoperatively was higher mean right atrial filling pressure in the
AP group (18.4 mm Hg vs 16.3 mm Hg, p=0.006) and the more frequent need for
reoperation in the AV group (28% vs 6%, p=0.013). Overall survival through 107
pt-yrs was 86% after AP connections versus 80% after AV connections. We
conclude that there are no clinically important differences in the early
results of physiologic repair of tricuspid atresia using AP versus AV
connection. The choice of either technique should be dictated by the anatomy of
the great arteries at the time of repair.
*By Invitation
8:50 a.m.
34. Extending the Limits for Modified Fontan
Procedures
JOHN E. MAYER, JR.,
RICHARD A. JONAS*,
ALDO R. CASTANEDA,
HRODMAR HELGASON*
and PETER LANG*
Boston,
Massachusetts
A variety of physiologic and anatomic limits have
been proposed by Fontan's group as predictors of the outcome after
atrio-pulmonary anastamotic (APA) procedures, but how far these limits can be
extended with successful oucome remains unclear. Since a large number of
complex cyanotic defects are physiologically correctable, only by APA procedures,
we have extended these limits in the areas of age, systemic venous or pulmonary
venous anomalies, pulmonary artery anatomy, and pulmonary hemodynamics. One or
more of these limits was exceeded in 89 of a total of 148 patients undergoing
APA procedures for tricuspid atresia (59) or more complex defects (89). The age
limit of 4-15 years was exceeded in 65 patients, 41 under 4 (range 4-47 months)
and 24 over 15 (range 16-30 years). Mortality was 34% under 4 years, 8.3% over
15 years, and 20% for the 4-15 year group. In the <4 group where other
anatomic and physiologic limits were not exceeded, mortality was reduced to
22%. If indexed pulmonary arteriolar resistance (PAR) was ≤1.5 Woods
units, 10 of 11 under 4 years survived, but if PAR was >1.5 units, only 8 of
19 survived. Abnormal pulmonary or systemic venous connections occurred in 11,
and 9 survived APA procedures combined with re-arrangement of venous drainage.
Pulmonary artery distortion requiring reconstruction occurred in 21 patients,
and 9 died (42%). Five of these deaths occurred in patients with PAR >2
units. The pulmonary artery pressure limit of 15 mmHg was exceeded in 25
patients, and 17 survived (68%). Of these, 19 had PAR <2 units and 17
survived (89%). All 6 patients with PAP >15 mmHg and PAR >2 units died.
Late follow-up of the 64 survivors exceeding one or more criteria shows 40 in
Class I, 11 in Class II, 3 late deaths, and 10 lost to follow-up. We conclude
that age, anomalies of pulmonary or systemic venous drainage, pulmonary artery
distortion, or elevated pulmonary artery pressure do not individually preclude
satisfactory outcome after APA procedures. Criteria for selection of patients
under 4 years should be more stringent than older patients, particularly
regarding calculated pulmonary arteriolar resistance.
9:00 a.m. Discussion
of the Fontan Procedure - Francis M. Fontan, Bordeaux, France
9:45 a.m. Intermission - Visit Exhibits -
Exhibit Hall
*By Invitation
10:30 a.m. Scientific Session - Grand Ballroom
35. A
New Technique for Repair of Aortic Coarctation: Subclavian Flap Aortoplasty
with Preservation of Arterial Blood Flow to the Left Arm
MILTON A. MEIER,
FERNANDO A. LUCCHESE*,
WALDIR JAZBIK*, IVO
A. NESRRALLA* and
JOSE TELES MENDONCA*
Rio de Janeiro,
Porto Alegre and Aracaju, Brazil
Sponsored by: JOHN
W. KIRKLIN, Birmingham, Alabama
Between 1967 and 1976, 106 children survived
Mustard procedure for transposition of great arteries (TGA). Fifty-five had
simple and 51 complex TGA. Their age ranged between 2 weeks and 117 months (median
= 12). Ninety-five patients (pts) had 121 previous palliative procedures.
Follow-up data up to 18 years (mean = 10.9 ± 3.3) is available on 98 (92.5%)
pts. Late death occurred in 8 pts (1 simple, 7 complex TGA) between 2 months to
13 years (mean = 4.6). Sudden death occurred in 4 pts., 2 died of congestive
heart failure, one of pulmonary vascular disease and one of tricuspid
re-gurgitation. Late Sinus node dysfunction occurred in 31 pts, 6 of these
required permanent pacemakers. Of these 31 pts, 17 had unroofing of coronary
sinus, while in 14, it was left intact. Postoperative cardiac catheterization
showed mild superior vena cava obstruction in 4, mild pulmonary venous
obstruction in 3 and baffle leak in 4 pts. Of these, one patient underwent
reoperation elsewhere for a baffle leak. Five pts. developed new subpulmonic
obstruction, two of which required resection and myotomy. Tricuspid
regurgitation occurred in 2, one underwent reoperation. The actuarial survival
for 10 years is 93 ± 2.4% and for 18 years is 91 ± 2.3% (95% confidence
interval). The probability of event-free survival at 18 years is 82 ± 3.8%
(number at risk = 69, events being death, reoperation and insertion of
permanent pacemaker). Eighty-seven pts. are in NYHA class I and 3 in class II.
Conclusions:
(1) Long-term and event-free survival has been satisfactory. (2) Late death
was signficiantly higher in complex TGA (P=.027). (3) Sinus node dysfunction
was common, but was not related to the unroofing of coronary sinus (p=NS). Of
these, only 6 pts. required permanent pacemakers. (4) The incidence of late
complications and reoperation was low.
10:40 a.m. Discussion
*By Invitation
10:50 a.m.
36. The Arterial Switch Operation: An Eight-Year
Experience
JAN M. QUAEGEBEUR *,
JOHN ROHMER *,
JAAP OTTENKAMP*,
TIJIK BUIS*,
JOHN W. KIRKLIN,
EUGENE H. BLACKSTONE
and A. GERARD BROM
Leiden, The
Netherlands and Birmingham, Alabama
Sixty-six patients (23 neonates with transposition
(TGA) and intact ventricular septum (VS), 33 infants and children with TGA and
large ventricular septal defect (VSD), and 10 with the Taussig-Bing heart) have
received an arterial switch operation as a routine since 1977. One with TGA and
intact VS, 6 with TGA and VSD, and 1 with the Taussig-Bing heart died in the
hospital. Including hospital deaths, 11 month overall actuarial survival was
81%, and no deaths occurred subsequently among the 33 patients traced
thereafter for as long as 8 years. The hazard function for death had only a
single early phase, and its confidence limits overlapped the hazard function of
a matched general population within 12 months of operation. Incremental risk
factors for death included low birth weight (but not weight or age at
operation), TGA with large VSD, the Taussig-Bing heart, and presence of a patent
ductus arteriosus (PDA). Coronary artery morphology and position of the great
arteries were not risk factors. Earlier date of operation was a risk factor
(P=.004), and among 27 patients operated upon since April 1984 there have been
no early or late deaths; 1 year survival, including hospital deaths, after
operation in 1985, predicted from the multivariate equation, is 99.9% (CL
98%-100%) for neonates with TGA and intact VS, and 99.6% (99%-99.9%) for those
with TGA and large VSD or the Taussig-Bing heart. The late functional results
were excellent, and the rhythm was sinus in 96% of the 55 surviving patients.
A formal comparison was made of these results with
those of the atrial switch and the intraventricular tunnel repair, which
indicates that the arterial switch repair is superior.
11:00 a.m. Discussion
*By Invitation
11:10 a.m.
37. Long-Term Evaluation of Homograft and
Heterograft Valves in Extracardiac Valved Conduits
JAROSLAV STARK*,
PAVEL HORVATH*,
RUI ALMEIDA *,
WALTER MERRILL*,
JAMES F.N. TAYLOR *,
CATHERINE BULL*,
FERGUS J. MACARTNEY*
and MARC R. DE LEVAL*
London, England
Sponsored by: JAMES
R. MALM New York, New York
Long-term results of 249 children, who received
extracardiac conduits between 1971 and December 1982 were evaluated. Follow-up
ranged from between 3 and 13 years. Major diagnostic groups were Truncus
Arteriosus (TA) 70, Transposition of the Great Arteries (TGA)/Double Outlet
Right Ventricle (DORV) complex 64, Fontan type operation 37, Pulmonary Atresia
(PA) and Ventricular Septal Defect (VSD) 29, Congenitally Corrected TGA (CTGA)
22 and miscellaneous 27. Aortic homografts (AH) preserved in nutrient and
antibiotic solution or deep frozen were used in 108, porcine heterografts (PH)
in 107, pericardial valves in 30 and valveless conduits in 6. Hospital
mortality related to the age of the patient, complexity of the lesion and
severity of the pre-operative condition. Hospital mortality was 77% in the
first 3 months of life, 33% between 1-4 years and 23% over the age of 4 years.
Status of survivors at the last follow-up was good in 92.5% and fair in 7.5%.
Late results were evaluated actuarially. Probability of survival at 5 and 10
years (hospital deaths excluded) for the major diagnostic group was: TGA/DORV
82%/50%, PA + VSD 90%/78%, TA 78%/70%. Probability of survial with the original
conduit for the same diagnostic group at 5 and 10 years was TGA/DORV 70%/45%,
PA + VSD 85%/25%, TA 62%/20%. At 5 years there was no difference in "conduit
survival" between AH and PH. At 10 years 50% of AH patients were alive with
their original conduit but only 30% of PH patients. Only 2 AH calcified and
became stenotic. Cause of obstruction in AH were related to peel formation in
dacron extension and anastomotic strictures. We conclude that AH conduits used
without dacron extension are preferable to PH in children. Collagen or
fibrinogen presealed dacron tubes may reduce peel formation, but our experience
with those techniques is too short for meaningful evaluation.
11:20 a.m. Discussion
*By Invitation
11:30 a.m.
38. Management
of Pulmonary Atresia with Intact Ventricular Septum
JOHN E. FOKER,
ELIZABETH A. BRAUNLIN*,
JOHN A. ST. CYR*,
DAVID HUNTER*, JAMES H. MOLLER*,
W. STEVES RING* and
J. ERNESTO MOLINA
Minneapolis,
Minnesota
Newborns with
pulmonary atresia with intact ventricular septum may also have suprasystemic
right ventricular (RV) pressures, tricuspid valve insufficiency, and
hypoplastic RVs and pulmonary arteries (PAs). The complexity of these lesions
is reflected in the variety of surgical approaches taken and the high mortality
rates reported. The purpose of this report is to document the advantages of
early RV decompression by a RV outflow tract patch (RVOP) and a variable
approach to the provision of adequate pulmonary blood flow (PBF). Fifteen
neonates, 1-3 days of age, with this diagnosis and suprasystemic RV pressures
were placed on prostaglandin E, (PGE1) prior to surgery to improve
PBF. Only 2/15 could be predicted to have satisfactory postoperative RV
mechanics and had an RVOP and ductus ligation. For 9/15 a RVOP was placed but
diminutive RV size and/or tricuspid incompetency precluded ductus ligation.
PGE, was infused postoperatively (average 6.8 days) to provide PBF in these
patients until RV function became adequate. In 3 infants with severely
hypoplastic RVs, early RV function was not anticipated, therefore, an
aortopulmonary shunt was placed in addition to decompression by a RVOP. One
infant, early in series, had only a shunt. Postoperatively, adequate PBF was
present in all and 11/15 (73%) survived. Three deaths (avg. 2.8 days) following
RVOP and PGE1 infusion were due to continued low cardiac output, not
primary hypoxia. One neonate with a RVOP and shunt died from myocardial
ischemia because of coronary artery steal through RV sinusoids. One late death
occurred in the child with only a shunt, presumably due to an arrhythmia. The
remaining survivors (10/15, 61%)are alive and completely repaired.
These patients have revealed that adequate RV size requires more liberal
definition. Four patients with a residual atrial septal defect (ASD) and a
right to left shunt at age 1-3 years, were found by angiography to have a
tricuspid valve diameter from 2.2-4.1 SE below the expected mean and RV volumes
below the fifth percentile. Nevertheless, balloon occlusion of the ASD revealed
the RVs were functionally adequate and the ASDs (in two, shunts were also
closed) could be repaired. In summary, all survivors are corrected in contrast
to reported studies in which many are functioning with shunts. Certain unifying
treatment principles have emerged: (1) RVOP can be performed in the neonatal
period with good results and maximizes the potential for RV growth by relief of
RV hypertension; (2) In most patients, PBF can be assured for at least 1-2
weeks with PGE, infusion. RV function usually improves and only rarely is shunt
placement required. (3) In cases of apparent inadequate RV size in follow-up,
RV function can be assessed preoperatively by balloon occlusion of the ASD and,
if tolerated, will be satisfactory after ASD closure.
11:40 a.m. Discussion
*By Invitation