American Association for
Thoracic Surgery
64TH ANNUAL MEETING
Scientific Program
MONDAY MORNING, May 7, 1984
8:30 a.m. Business Session (Limited to Members)
Grand Ballroom - Third Floor
8:45 a.m. Scientific Session - Grand Ballroom -
Third Floor
1. Computed Tomography: An Effective Technique
for Mediastinal Staging in Lung Cancer
BENEDICT D.T. DALY*,
L. JACK FAILING*,
ROBERTD. PUGATCH*,
Y. JUNG-LEGG*,
M. ELON GALE*,
GUNARS BITE*
and GORDON L.
SNIDER*
Boston,
Massachusetts
Sponsored by: HAROLD
F. RHEINLANDER
Boston, Massachusetts
Computed tomographic (CT) scans of the chest were utilized to stage the
mediastinum in 148 instances of bronchogenic carcinoma considered for resection
in 146 patients. Nodes > 1.5 cm in size were interpreted as abnormal. All nodes
positive by CT were evaluated by mediastinoscopy (31), anterior mediastinotomy
(7), or thoracotomy (7) depending on their anatomic location. All patients with
negative findings underwent thoracotomy without prior surgical staging.
Patients undergoing thoracotomy for staging or resection were divided into two
Groups. In Group I (first 51 instances), routine mediastinal exploration was
not carried out; in Group II Oast 97 instances) the mediastinum was explored in
every patient and nodes were submitted for histopathology. This report compares
the CT and pathologic findings on the mediastinal lymph nodes.
|
#
Patients
|
True Positive
|
True Negative
|
False Positive
|
False Negative
|
Sensitivity
|
Specificity
|
Accuracy
|
|
Group
I
|
15
|
32
|
2
|
2
|
88%
|
94%
|
92%
|
|
Group
11
|
18
|
65
|
8
|
6
|
75%
|
89%
|
86%
|
|
Central
Tumor
|
26
|
38
|
9
|
4
|
87%
|
81%
|
83%
|
|
Peripheral
Tumor
|
7
|
59
|
1
|
4
|
64%
|
98%
|
93%
|
Ten patients had false-positive scans, two
with extensive granulomatous disease and seven with postobstructive
pneumonitis; nine of the ten had central lesions and seven were located in the
right upper lobe. Eight patients had false negative scans, six had either
paraaortic or subaortic nodes (4) or posterior subcarinal nodes (2). These
nodes would not have been accessible to mediastinoscopy. One patient had
positive low paratracheal and subcarinal nodes but the metastases were focal
and intranodal. One patient had small paratracheal nodes replaced by tumor and
is the only patient with false negative nodes in whom routine mediastinoscopy
would have prevented thoracotomy and resection. We believe CT staging of the
mediastinum is indicated for all patients with lung cancer in whom surgery is
contemplated. CT directs the most appropriate staging procedure for patients
with positive findings and obviates mediastinoscopy for patients with negative
findings.
*By Invitation
2. Adverse Prognostic Effect of N2 in
Treated Small Cell Carcinoma of The Lung
JOHN A. MEYER, JOHN
J. GULLO*,
PHILLIP M. IKINS*,
ROBERT L. COMIS*,
WILLIAM A. BURKE*
and FREDERICK B. PARKER, JR.
Syracuse, New York
Patients treated nonsurgically for "limited" small
cell carcinoma of the lung relapse most frequently within the chest. We have
sought to control this mode of treatment failure by adjunctive surgical
resection, in addition to chemotherapy. Since 1975, we have treated patients
with disease in clinical Stages I and II by initial resection and the full
course of chemotherapy thereafter. Beginning in 1979, suitable patients with
Stage III-MO disease (T3 and/or N2, MO) have been treated initially with two
cycles of chemotherapy, followed by resection of the primary tumor, dissection
of mediastinal nodes, prophylactic cranial irradiation, and continuing
chemotherapy. Diagnosis of N2 in this study was made by positive biopsy at
mediastinoscopy (nine cases), or in one case by CT demonstration of enlarged
subcarinal nodes, plus later histologic finding of tumor in the excised nodes.
Patients classified here as NO or N1 had negative mediastinoscopy, and no
radiographic evidence of mediastinal node enlargement.
Many reviews find that continuing complete
remission at 30 months after the start of treatment may be considered
equivalent to disease eradication. Thirteen of our patients without the finding
of N2 began treatment more than 30 months ago (three T3 N1; four T2 N1; four T2
NO; two T1 NO); one has died of a surgical complication and two (T3 N1, T2 N1)
have suffered relapse at 14 and 17 months. The other ten patients (77%) have
remained disease free.
Conversely, all of the first ten patients with
an initial finding of N2 have developed known relapse within this period (nine
patients), or in one instance, died at home with suspected recurrent disease.
Known recurrences have appeared in the liver in four cases; in liver plus bone
in two; in meninges, in opposite main bronchus, and in lung, one case apiece.
Two relapses appeared very late, at 27 and 30 months after the start of
treatment.
These findings suggest that disease control is
possible in the majority of MO patients without demonstrable mediastinal node involvement.
The initial finding of N2 may be indicative of dissemination sufficient in most
cases to interfere with the patient's chances for long survival.
*By Invitation
3. Survival Following Sequential Resections
for Second or Third Primary Lung Cancers
DOUGLAS J.
MATHISEN*, ROBERT J. JENSIK,
L. PENFIELD FABER
and C. FREDERICK KITTLE
Chicago, Illinois
The performance of sequential resections and the
consideration of new lesions as second or third primary lung cancers remain
controversial issues. Criteria to define these as new primary lesions depend
upon a difference in histologic types, a prolonged interval between initial and
second or third resections, and location in the contralateral lung or a
different ipsilateral lobe. Ninety patients have undergone multiple resections
for bronchogenic carcinoma from 1962 to November 1983. There were 10 examples
of synchronous lesions and the remaining 78 were metachronous with the longest
interval between resections being 17 years and four months.
The initial surgical procedures were
pneumonectomy-11; lobectomy-42; sleeve lobectomy-9; segmentectomy-27; carinal
resection-1. At the second operation, the procedures were: Segmentectomy-55;
lobectomy-11; completion lobectomy-6; completion pneumonectomy-15. Two patients
had sternotomy with bilateral resections and one patient had a tracheal
resection. The third procedures were: Segmentectomy-6; completion
segmentectomy-1; completion lobectomy-2; completion pneumonectomy-2.
In 18 patients undergoing the second procedure
and 2 undergoing a third resection, a different cell type was identified. The
peri-operative mortality following the second operation was 7 of 90 patients
(8%), and there were no deaths in those patients undergoing three resections.
Cumulative survival following second resection
in 78 patients with metachronous tumors was 33% at 5 years and 20% at 10 years.
*By Invitation
4. Experience With Primary Neoplasms of The
Trachea and Carina
F. GRIFFITH PEARSON,
THOMAS T.R. TODD*
and JOEL D. COOPER
Toronto, Ontario
Between 1963 and 1983, forty-three patients
were seen with primary malignant tracheal neoplasms and managed on our surgical
service. The final pathology was adenoid cystic carcinoma - 28 cases, squamous
cell carcinoma - 8 cases, leiomyosarcoma - 4 cases, and 3 miscellaneous
tumours.
Thirty-two patients were managed by resection
and primary anastomosis: trachea only -12, trachea and carina -12, trachea and
cricoid - 4, trachea and larynx - 4. There were two operative deaths.
Six patients had defects replaced with a heavy
duty Mrlex prosthesis, and all but one of these was operated on during the
1960's. Three of six died post-operatively due to innominate artery erosion.
Three patients with non-resectable tumours
were treated with an indwelling silicone stent: one Montgomery T-tube, two
silicone TY-tubes. All three had worthwhile palliation. Two patients with
extensive, but non-obstructive adenoid cystic carcinomas were managed by
primary irradiation. Good clinical remission has been maintained in each at 30
and 36 months respectively.
The following observations are noted:
1) Adjunctive radiotherapy was used (either
pre or post-operatively) in patients with adenoid cystic carcinoma. No patient
having a complete resection has suffered a recognizable clinical recurrence.
Furthermore, even patients with incomplete resections achieve good long-term
palliation in most cases. This includes four patients with slowly progressive,
asymptomatic pulmonary metastases.
2) Resection of cricoid with sparing of the
larynx is possible in occasional patients with primary malignancies of the
proximal airway.
3) With experience it is apparent that median
sternotomy provides the best exposure for selected cases requiring carinal
resection.
10:00 a.m. Intermission - Visit Exhibits - Second
Floor
Complimentary Coffee
*By Invitation
10:45 a.m. Scientific Session - Grand Ballroom - Third
Floor
5. Pulmonary Artery Banding
ROBERT A. ALDUS*,
GEORGE A. TRUSLER,
TERUO IZUKAWA* and
WILLIAM G. WILLIAMS*
Toronto, Ontario
From January 1972 through December 1982, 209
patients underwent pulmonary artery banding at The Hospital for Sick Children,
Toronto. A method for estimating the required band circumference was used in
all children without significant pulmonary vascular disease. Children were
divided into four categories according to diagnosis. Infants in Group I had
ventricular septal defect (VSD), atrioventricular septal defect (AVD) or double
outlet right ventricle with a subaortic VSD (DORVA). We attempted to band these
infants tightly at a band circumference of 20mm + 1mm for each kilogram of
infant body weight. Overall mortality was low (9%), response was moderate or
good (89%) and pulmonary hypertension was well controlled (normal pulmonary
artery pressure at subsequent repair in 88%). The highest mortality occurred in
infants with VSD and coarctation of the aorta (16%). Group II infants had
complete transposition of the great arteries (TGA) with VSD, double outlet
right ventricle with a subpulmonic VSD, single ventricle or tricuspid atresia.
These infants were banded more loosely at 24mm + 1mm for each kilogram of
infant body weight. Overall mortality was good (13.5%), response to banding was
moderate or good in 86% and subsequent pulmonary artery pressure was normal in
79%. Group III consisted of infants with mitral atresia, mitral stenosis and a
variety of other complex lesions. Control of congestive cardiac failure was
only slight or moderate, and early and late mortality was high.
Pulmonary artery banding by this method allows
for safe and effective control of congestive cardiac failure and pulmonary
hypertension in infants with congenital heart disease and excessive pulmonary
blood flow.
*By Invitation
6. Valvotomy for Pulmonary Atresia with Intact
Ventricular Septum: A Disciplined Approach to Achieve a Functioning Right
Ventricle
ADNAN COBANOGLU*,
MARK T. METZDORFF*,
C. WRIGHT PINSON*,
GARY L. GRUNKEMEIER*
and ALBERT STARR
Portland, Oregon
During the past 20 years, a consistent policy in
applying early valvotomy has resulted in a unique opportunity to appraise the
long-term results of this approach in pulmonary atresia with intact ventricular
septum (PA:IVS). Since 1964, 27 of 35 patients with PA:IVS had Type 1 or 2
right ventricle (RV); 25 of these had early valvotomy, 7 with and 18 without
concomitant shunt. The remaining 2 patients with Type 2 RV and the 8 patients
with Type 3 RV were treated with shunt alone. The overall operative mortality
was 34%; those patients weighing more than 3 kilograms and those operated since
1977 had operative mortalities of 18% and 16% respectively. There were 17
survivors of early valvotomy: 12 had valvotomy alone and 5 valvotomy with
shunt; 12 had Type 1 RV and 5 Type 2 RV. Survival (± standard error) for these
17 patients was 85(± 10)% and 68(± 17)% at 5 and 10 years respectively. The
probability of reoperation was 100% by 6 years of age, with outflow patch
reconstruction successfully employed in all cases where reoperation has been
performed. Aggressive follow-up and early recatheterization were essential
features of management. Delayed reconstruction after shunt alone was
unsuccessful in 3 patients, 2 with Type 3 RV and 1 with Type 2 RV.
Primary direct valvotomy without shunt is the operation of choice for
patients with PA:IVS and Type 1 RV. Concomitant shunt may be required for some
Type 1 and most Type 2 RV patients, selected preoperatively by angiography or
postoperatively by clinical necessity. Delayed right ventricle reconstruction
after shunt alone is not an acceptable approach when an outflow tract is
present.
11:30 a.m. Presidential Address - Grand Ballroom -
Third Floor
A Laboratory For Progress
DWIGHT C. McGOON
12:15 p.m. Adjourn for Lunch - Visit Exhibits
*By Invitation