MONDAY
AFTERNOON, May 3, 1982
2:00 p.m. Forum Session - Assembly Hall
7.
Improved
Myocardial Protection With Decreasing Temperature During Cardioplegic Arrest
F.L. ROSENFELDT* and
G.R. STIRLING*,
Victoria, Australia
Sponsored by: David
C. Sabiston, Jr., Durham,
North Carolina
The relationship between
recovery and temperature during cardioplegic arrest was studied in canine
hearts perfused by a support dog. Isolated hearts underwent 2 hours of arrest
between -3°C and 37°C using the St. Thomas' Hospital (K+, Mg++, procaine)
solution. Isovolumic left ventricular (LV) developed pressure (DP) was measured
before and after arrest. LV biopsies were taken for lactate assay before and
for ATP assay and electron microscopy after arrest. The results showed
ultrastructural damage only at -3°C and a decrease in protection around
15-20°C:
|
Temp. °C
|
-3
|
4
|
15
|
20
|
25
|
30
|
37
|
|
n
|
4
|
6
|
7
|
5
|
8
|
6
|
2
|
|
DP % control
|
0
|
100
|
98
|
95
|
89
|
60
|
4
|
|
ATP<% control
|
24
|
96
|
106
|
88
|
86
|
60
|
12
|
|
Lactate µM/a
|
1.5
|
1.8
|
3.1
|
6.6
|
9.2
|
13.8
|
33.3
|
In a further study arrest was prolonged for 6 hours to bring out
differences in protection in the lower temperature range:
|
Temperature
|
°C
|
4 (n = 6)
|
12 (n = 6)
|
20 (n = 5)
|
|
DP (mmHg):
|
Reperfusion
|
103 ± 5
|
96 ± 5
|
56 ± 5
|
|
ATP µM/g:
|
Control
|
3.8 ± 0.2
|
3.9 ± 0.2
|
3.6 ± 0.2
|
|
|
2 hours
|
3.7 ± 0.2
|
3.9 ± 0.1
|
3.2 ± 0.1
|
|
|
4 hours
|
3.4 ± 0.2
|
3.3 ± 0.2
|
2.4 ± 0.2
|
|
|
6 hours
|
2.6 ± 0.2
|
2.1 ± 0.2
|
0.9 ± 0.3
|
|
|
Reperfusion
|
2.6 ± 0.1
|
2.1 ± 0.1
|
1.1 ± 0.2
|
Values given are mean ± SEM. Analysis of variance was used for
statistical comparisons.
ATP was depleted
progressively with time in all groups but most rapidly at 20°C. After
reperfusion, the 20°C group showed significantly lower biochemical and
functional recovery than the other 2 groups (P<0.001) and the 12°C group
showed lower biochemical recovery than the 4°C group (P<0.01).
Conclusion:Protection varies inversely with myocardial temperature and although
this effect is most marked down to 20°C there are further increases in
protection with cooling to 4°C.
*By invitation
8. Critical Importance of Topical Hypothermia
In Cooling Myocardial Regions Supplied by Collateral Flow
JOHN C. LASCHINGER*,
FRANK P. CATINELLA*,
JOSEPH N.
CUNNINGHAM, JR., PETER X. ADAMS*,
IRA M. NATHAN* and
FRANK C. SPENCER,
New York, New York
The importance of profound hypothermia in
protecting the myocardium during cardioplegic arrest is well known. However, as
is often the case in pts. with severe coronary artery disease, regions of the
myocardium distal to critical stenoses supplied solely by small collateral
vessels are underperfused and inadequately cooled. The following study was
undertaken in a canine model of chronic progressive coronary occlusion to
assess the importance of added topical hypothermia in augmenting myocardial
cooling in regions of collateral flow.
Dogs (12) had hydroscopic ameroid constrictors
placed at the origin of the circumflex coronary artery and mid-left anterior
descending coronary artery. Eight weeks later after angiographic demonstration
of vessel occlusion and collateral development, myocardial ischemia was
confirmed by atrial pacing (180 BPM) and noting ST changes. Animals underwent
60 min. of aortic crossclamping (AXC). Hearts were protected with topical
hypothermia (normal saline, temp. 4°C) and blood cardioplegia (temp. 10°C, pH
8.0, KC1 30 mEqs/L, 1 initially and then 500 cc every 30 min.). Subendocardial
temperatures in both normal and collateralized myocardial regions were measured
with thermistor probes after each injection and following the addition of 1
liter of topical hypothermia (TH).
The results are as follows (all values
expressed as mean ± SEM):
|
|
|
DISTAL LAD
|
|
RIGHT
|
|
|
SEPTUM
|
REGION
|
CX REGION
|
VENTRICLE
|
|
Post Injection
|
12 ± .6°C
|
15 ± .9°C
|
13 ± .6°C
|
13 ± .7°C
|
|
Post TH
|
12 ± .7°C
|
11 ± .6°C
|
12 ± .6°C
|
9 ± .4°C
|
|
P Value
|
NS
|
<.001
|
<.025
|
<.001
|
These data demonstrate the
importance of adjunctive topical hypothermia in cooling regions of the
myocardium distal to critical coronary stenoses with poor distribution of
cardioplegia solution. Furthermore, cooling those areas of the myocardium with
the greatest amount of surface area exposed to ambient temperatures (e.g.
anterior right ventricle) will also be improved.
*By invitation
9. Benefits
of Normothermic Blood Cardioplegic Induction of Prolonged, Multidose Cold Blood
Cardioplegia in Energy Depleted Hearts
ELIOT R.
ROSENKRANZ*,
JAKOB
VINTEN-JOHANSEN*,
GERALD D. BUCKBERG
and HANNIBAL EDWARDS*
Los Angeles, California
High risk cardiac patients arc more vulnerable
to intraopcrative damage because myocardial ATP depletion may be present before
aortic clamping and therefore limit myocardial recovery following cardioplegia.
To simulate this experimentally, we produced 47%* ATP depletion in dogs by 45
minutes of normothermic ischemic arrest, followed immediately thereafter by 2
more hours of aortic clamping with 4°C multidose blood cardioplegia. We
compared the effects of starting the blood cardioplegic infusion at 37 °C (for
5 minutes before cooling it 10 4°C) with those of immediate 4°C blood
cardioplegic infusion. The study was designed lo determine if the initial 37 °C
blood cardioplegic infusion would enhance energy replenishment by allowing more
oxidative metabolism than that possible if the Q10 effect of 4°C
hypothermia was immediate.
During the 5 minute period of
cardioplegic induction, dogs receiving 37°C initial blood cardioplegia had a
3.3cc/100g/min* (421%)* greater oxygen uptake than when 4°C blood cardioplegia
was used. Post-ischemic ventricular function recovered only 33%* in 10 control
dogs undergoing only 45 minutes of aortic clamping (no cardioplegia). Better
functional recovery, to 74%* of control, occurred in 5 dogs undergoing an
additional 2 hours of aortic clamping when 4°C multidoes blood cardioplegia was
used. In contrast, complete recovery (100%)* at a 42% lower left atrial
pressure was seen in the four dogs receiving the same cardioplegia dose, but
where the first 5 minutes of cardioplegic infusion was warmed to 37°C before
inducing myocardial hypothermia.
We conclude that, in energy depleted hearts,
enhancing myocardial oxidative metabolism by giving the initial blood
cardioplegia dose at 37°C (before inducing hypothermia) improves the heart's
tolerance to the subsequent aortic clamping required for cardiac repair.
*p < 0.05 compared
with control
*By invitation
10. The Control of Myocardial Ca++
Sequestration With Nifedipine/Potassium Cardioplegia
STUART L. BOE*,
CHARLES M. DIXON*,
TAMARA A. SAKERT*
and GEORGE J. MAGOVERN
Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania
AIM: To determine (a) when and to what extent
calcium ion (Ca++) accumulation occurs in the ischemic and
reperfused myocardium; (b) Can Ca++ uptake be inhibited by a
specific Ca++ antagonist, Nifedipine? METHOD: Mongrel dogs were
placed on total cardiopulmonary bypass at 32°C. Aortic crossclamp (AXC) was
applied for 1 hour and 300 cc. of cardio-plegic solution at 4°C was infused al
30 minute intervals. Fifteen minutes after AXC,45CaCl was injected
into the femoral artery, and a steady state of 45Ca distribution
maintained for 130 minutes. Myocardial biopsies were taken after 1 hour of AXC
(T0) and T5, T,0, T,5, T20,
T30 minutes of reperfusion. The source of the 45Ca++
available to the myocardium was the Serum Ca++expressed as the
Specific Activity (SA = [(cpm X 104)/1.0 gm]). and myocardial uptake
expressed as Relative Specific Activity (RSA ={(SA tissue)/ (SA serum)]). Group
1 (N = 10) received standard cardioplegic solution (SCS). Group II (N = 10)
received SCS plus Nifedipine, 20 me/kg. T0 values represent
sequestration of 45Ca++ in the myocardium via collaterals
despite one hour AXC. During all time frames of reperfusion, Nifedipine
significantly (p < .01) inhibited myocardial uptake. The results show
Nifedipine 1) aids maintenance of calcium ion homeostasis during AXC and
reperfusion; and 2) blocks calcium influx into the ischemic myocardium during
reperfusion. The delay of RSA returning to unity in Group II implies a
beneficial effect by inhibiting Ca+ + transport in early
reperfusion, preventing excessive energy consumption by mitochondrial Ca'
sequestration, best illustrated in Group I at T20 when Ca++
uptake was 5 times normal and confirmed by reduced ATP levels in previous
studies. This histochemical sludy provides a rationale for the previously shown
improved experimental and clinical hemodynamic function when Nifedipine is added
to standard hyperkalemic cardioplegia.
|
RELATIVE SPECIFIC ACTIVITY
|
|
TIME
|
GROUP I
|
GROUP II
|
|
T0
|
0.92 ± .09
|
0.63 ± .03
|
|
T5
|
1.74 ± .07
|
0.67 ± .02
|
|
T10
|
1.92 ± .06
|
0.69 ± .02
|
|
T15
|
2.30 ± .18
|
0.75 ± .02
|
|
T20
|
5.15 ± .56
|
0.78 ± .02
|
|
T30
|
2.17 ± .06
|
1.31 ± .03
|
*By invitation
11. Experimental Evaluation of Magnesium
Cardioplegia
AKIO WAKABAYASHI, TSUNEHIRO NISHI*
AND EDWARD J. GUILMETTE*
Irvine, California
Magnesium is a major active ingredient in all
three representative European cardioplegic solutions bul its effectiveness has
not been well defined because their data were based on experiments involving
multiple components. Therefore, the present study was undertaken to determine
the protective effect of magnesium per sc using it as a sole active ingredient.
Methods. Thirty-six excised rabbits hearts were perfused with
oxygenated blood, while the maximal net developed tension (TNmax) of
the isometrically contracting posterior papillary muscle was determined. When TNmax
became stabilized, anoxic normothermic cardioplegia was induced by infusing 10
ml of either control solution (Na+ 135, K+ 5, Cl- 140 mEq/L) or test
solution (Mg+ + 140, SO4-- 140 mEq/L) into the aortic
cannula. The heart was immersed in a waterbath (37 C) for 30, 45, or 60 min.,
six experiments in each group. Percent recovery of TN|1,.IX
was detemined after a full recovery. Results: Magnesium solution
induced cardiac arrest within one minute which was significantly faster than
the control (10.9 ± 1.9 min). The time required to restart the contractions
with reperfusion was not significantly different between the control and test
groups. After 30 minutes of magnesium anoxia, % recovery was 91.3 ± 8.3, which
was significantly (p<0.01) better than the controls 77.7 ± 4.1. When the
anoxic time was more than 45 min., however, this protective effect of magnesium
could not be demonstrated; after 45 min., 65.1 ± 16 (control) vs. 55.1 ± 27.1
(magnesium), after 60 min. anoxia, 4.5 ± 5.1 (control) vs 18.6 ± 11.1
(magnesium). Conclusion: Magnesium per se has a protective effect
on ischemic myocardium. Percent recovery of myocardial contractility following
30 minutes of normothermic anoxia observed in the present study was very
similar to the result achieved by potassium (40 mEq/1) or procaine (0.02%) in
our earlier studies. As with these two other active cardioplegic agents,
however, the protective effect of magnesium rapidly diminishes as an anoxic
time exceeds 30 minutes at normothermia.
*By invitation
12. Adequacy of the Reperfusate: Its Influence In
Successful Myocardial Protection
IGNACIO Y.
CHRISTLIEB* and RICHARD E. CLARK
St. Louis, Missouri
Previous experiments have indicated that the
characteristics of the perfusate at the initiation of myocardial reperfusion
after long ischemic inervals (180 min) and long hypothermic (22°C) perfusion
times (220 ± 10 min) influenced post ischemic myocardial function despite
adequate protection during ischemia. 6 dogs (Group A) were perfused with 5%
glucose in Ringer's solution (290 mOsmol) and 6 dogs (Group B) were perfused
with 5% glucose-hetastarch solution containing mannitol (osm = 360 ± 20
mOsmol). Priming volumes and oxygenators were identical in the two groups.
Perfusion times, and base excess (+ 6 - 8 mEq/L) at the initiation of
reperfusion after 3 hr. of global ischemia were equal. Both groups had had
identical number and composition of cardioplegic infusions. Complete
hemodynamic studies demonstrated that the two groups were equal in terms of
cardiac index (CI), left ventricular stroke work index (LVSWI), LVEDP, LV dP/dt
and response to volume loading prior to perfusion. 120 min. after cessation of
perfusion, the group A dogs had 50% of normal LVSWI (10-12 gm-m/m2)
versus 20-22 gm-m/m2 for group B dogs. CI's were 1.9 ± 2 vs. 3.6 ± 3
for the A and B groups respectively. Group A dogs had a flat response to volume
loading 100 min. after initiation of reperfusion in contrast to group B which
had a normal response. Group A required more crystalloid and buffer addition
during perfusion. It is concluded that low sodium concentrations,
hyperosmolarity and onconicity of the perfusate particularly at the onset of
reperfusion significantly influences the myocardial performance immediately and
for 2 hrs. after cessation of cardiopulmonary bypass in dogs. These data
suggest that the reperfusion phase of cardiac operations is as important as the
composition and administration of cardioplegic solutions and may acccount for
differences in reports between investigators.
*By invitation
13. Platelet Deposition After Surgically Induced
Myocardial Ischemia: An Etiologic Factor For Reperfusion Injury
HAROLD FEINBERG*, DAVID ROSENBAUM*,
SIDNEY LEVITSKY and NORMAN A. SILVERMAN*
Chicago, Illinois
Despite meticulous adherence to presently
known principles of myocardial preservation, reperfusion after aortic
cross-clamping results in a unique injury manifested by decreasing high energy
phosphate levels and increased coronary resistance. We hypothesize that
platelet deposition (PD) into the coronary microvasculature is a major factor
in reperfusion injury. To differentiate PD due to subendocardial hemorrhage
from deposition to vascular entrapment, 111In-labeled platelets
together with 51Cr-labeled erythrocytes were infused in 15 dogs on
normothermic bypass and subjected to 60 minutes of global ischemia followed by
30 minutes of reperfusion. PD is indicated only when the proportion of
platelets to erythrocytes in tissue exceeds that measured in peripheral blood.
Myocardial biopsies were obtained after 120 minutes of continuous bypass (Group
I) and at the end of reperfusion after global ischemia (Group II). In 5 dogs
(Group III), dipyridamole (1 mg/kg), a potent anti-platelet activation agent,
was administered in the pre-ischemic period. PD was expressed as a ratio of 111In
before and after ischemia.

Bypass for 120 min. resulted in only a minimal increase in PD. However,
normothermic ischemia followed by reperfusion resulted in over a twofold
increase in PD compared to controls.. Pre-treatment with dipyridamole appeared
to avoid PD. These data indicate that platelet deposition in the coronary
microcirculation following surgically induced myocardial ischemia may be
associated with reperfusion injury and that anti-platelet drugs alter this
sequence.
3:15 p.m. Intermission - Visit Exhibits
*By invitation
4:00 p.m. Scientific Sessions - Assembly Hall
14. A Critical Reassessment of the Performance
Characteristics of the Starr-Edwards 6120 Mitral Valve Prosthesis Ten Years
Later
D. CRAIG MILLER*,
PHILIP E. OYER*,
EDWARD B. STINSON*,
BRUCE A. REITZ*,
STUART W. JAMIESON*,
WILLIAM A. BAUMGARTNER*
and NORMAN E.
SHUMWAY Stanford, California
Hesitancy regarding the long-term (10 yr) durability of porcine
bioprostheses and the thrombotic complictions associated with tilting-disc
mechanical prostheses have prompted resurgence in use of the Starr-Edwards
(S-E) metal strut, silastic poppet (Model 6120) mitral valve. Despite 16 years
of clinical availability, comprehensive data pertaining to its 10-15 year
performance characteristics are unavailable. Therefore, we assessed the
long-term results attained with this valve in 509 patients undergoing isolated
MVR between 1965-1974. Folow-up totalled 3,157 patient-years (pt-yrs), extended
to 15.5 yr maximum, and averaged (±SD) 9.8 ± 3.7 yrs. 124 pts were followed >10
yrs. Specific emphasis was focused on valve-related morbidity and mortality.
Anticoagulant-related hemorrhage (ACH) occurred at a linearized rate of
3.8%/pt-yr, thromboembolism (TE) at 5.7%/pt-yr, MVR reoperation (RE-OP) at
1.6%/pt-yr, valve failure (VF; defined by one or more of the following
criteria: new murmur of mitral regurgitation, thrombotic or tissue valvular
occlusion or multiple TEs leading to reoperation or death, or prosthetic valve
endocarditis causing reoperation or death) at 3.5%/pt-yr, and late death at
7.2%/pt-yr. Actuarial rates (± SEM) of being free of these complications were:
|
|
ACH
|
TE
|
RE-OP
|
VF
|
Late Death
|
|
5 years
|
81 ± 2%
|
65 ± 2%
|
93 ± 1%
|
79 ± 2%
|
71 ± 2%
|
|
10 years
|
67 ± 3%
|
55 ± 3%
|
84 ± 2%
|
73 ± 2%
|
47 ± 3%
|
|
14 years
|
52 ± 5%
|
48 ± 3%
|
80 ± 3%
|
69 ± 3%
|
38 ± 4%
|
54% (60/111) were caused by
multiple TE episodes. Although the intrinsic structural integrity of the S-E
6120 prosthesis is sound for 10-15 yrs, its overall "durability" is clearly
suboptimal due to tissue and thrombotic valvular obstruction, thromboemboli,
and other factors. Furthermore, when anticoagulant-related hemorrhage is added
to each patient's calculated risk equation, the overall incidence of S-E
valve-related mobidity at 10 yrs appears to favor tissue bioprostheses even if
20-30% or more of xenografts were to require replacement by 10 yrs. Only
similar large scale comparative analyses of the performance characteristics of
xenografts and tilting-dise valves in this time frame will resolve these
questions.
*By invitation
15. Early Valve Replacement In Active Infective
Endocarditis: Results and Late Survival
RAMON A CUKINGNAN*,
JOSEPH S. CAREY,
JOHN H. WITTIG* and
GEORGE E. CIMOCHOWSKI*,
Inglewood and Los
Angeles, California
In the last 14 years, 42 patients with active
infective endocarditis underwent early valve replacements because of severe
congestive heart failure, major prosthetic dehiscence, intramyocardial
abscesses, or major embolization. Forty patients had positive blood cultures,
and in 2 others, the valve tissues were positive. All patients were on
antimicrobials for greater than 1 week and under 4 weeks. Drug addiction was
noted in 24%, urinary tract manipulation in 7%, dental work in 5%, and unknown
cause in 64%. Organisms were predominantly Staphylococcal (43%) and Streptococcal
(41%) and 16% were gram negative (9%) or fungal (7%). The aortic valve was
involved in 72%, mitral in 14%, tricuspid in 7%, and both aortic and mitral in
7%. By NYHA class, 90% (38/42) were in Class III or IV.
Operative mortality was 10% (4/42), and all
had pre-existing renal failure. No predominant organism correlated with early
deaths. In aortic valve replacement (30 patients), operative mortality was 7%.
Postoperatively, 94% (35/37) are Class I or II with 1 lost to follow-up.
Subsequent reoperation was required in 5 patients (13%) for recurrent
endocarditis and major valve dehiscence with an operative mortality of 20%
(1/5). Late death occurred in 45% (17/38), being 43% for aortic valves, 67% for
mitral, 30% for tricuspid, and none for the combined. Major causes of death
were sudden death, recurrent endocarditis, and unknown cause. On analyzing
early and late mortality, all patients with fungal endocarditis were dead on
follow-up. Similarly, Ser-ratia and Pseudomonas infections resulted in a 100%
mortality. Staphylococcal endocarditis had a follow-up mortality of 44%
compared to 41% for Streptococcal species. Overall survival by life-table
method was 0.71 at 1 year and 0.52 at 5 years. Aortic valve endocarditis has a
5-year survival of 0.58.
This study shows that early operation after at
least 1 week of antibiotics in patients with active endocarditis has an
operative mortality comparable to non-infected valve replacements. Clinical
improvement is excellent in 94%. Poor overall late survival may be due to the
more virulent fungal, Staphylococcus epidermidis, and gram-negative organisms.
*By invitation
16. Left Ventricular Outflow Enlargement Using the
Konno Procedure
GREGORY A. MISBACH*,
KEVIN TURLEY*,
DANIEL J. ULLYOT and
PAUL A. EBERT
San Francisco, California
The management of patients with small aortic
annulus or left ventricular outflow tract obstruction remains unclear. Between
1976 and 1981, 14 patients have undergone enlargement of their left ventricular
outflow tract, using the Konno or a modification of the Konno type procedure.
Ten of these 14 patients had previous operations for aortic stenosis or tunnel
left ventricular outflow tract and two patients had undergone three previous
operations. All 14 patients had symptoms of either heart failure or chest pain,
or had electrocardiograph evidence of strain. They ranged in age from 5 years
to 57 years, with 12 of the 14 patients being less than 25 years of age.
A dacron patch was used to enlarge the left ventricular outflow tract
after incising down the ventricular septum. In all patients, at least a 23mm
valve was able to be placed with between 50 and 65 percent of the valve annulus
being made up of natural tissue. The remaining portion of the valve annulus was
constructed from the dacron patch. The patch was extended up the aorta to
enlarge the ascending aorta and a pericardial patch was used to close the
defect in the right ventricular outflow tract. In all 14 patients the gradient
was obliterated at the time of operation. There were no operative deaths, but
there has been one late death due to bacterial endocarditis in a child who also
had a parachute mitral valve and evidence of pulmonary hypertension. The
remaining 13 patients are functioning well after the Konno procedure. Two are receiving
Coumadin, and 11 are receiving aspirin. These results suggest that this is an
acceptable method of treating patients with small aortic annulus or left
ventricular outflow tract obstructions and would appear to have advantages over
a left ventricular apical aortic conduit.
*By invitation
17. The Surgical Treatment of Ventricular
Tachycardias (Simple Aneurysmectomy Versus Electrophysiologically Guided
Surgery)
JORG OSTERMEYER*,
RALF KOLVENBACK*,
GUNTER BREITHARDT*,
LUDGER SEIPEL*,
HAGEN D. SCHULTE* and
WOLFGANG BIRCKS
Dusseldorf, West
Germany
Sponsored by: JOHN
W. KIRKLIN,
Birmingham, Alabama
Between 1975 and 1981 35 patients had surgery
for life threatening recurrent ventricular tachycardia (VT) resistant to
antiarrhythmic drug therapy. All except of 3 had severe coronary artery disease
with a history of myocardial infarction. In 10 patients (group I) a simple
aneurysmectomy was done, 25 (group II) had an electrophysiologically guided
(epicardial/endocar-dial mapping) encircling endocardia! ventriculotomy at the
earliest electrical activity during VT. There were no significant differences
between the groups in age, sex ratio, NYHA class, coronary disease, aneurysm
location, concom-mittant bypass grafting and left ventricular function.
All patients have been restudied by means of
24h-ECG-monitoring, programmed stimulation and/or the
ECG-signal-averaging-technique 2-4weeks after surgery. The mean
follow-up period in group I is 3,8 years, in group II 22,8 weeks. In group I we
had 1 early and 4 late deaths after surgery (50%mortality) mainly due
to persistent arrhythmias. 1 patient is free of VT (10%), 3 require still
antiarrhythmics, 1 patient's post-operative history is unknown. Out of group II
we lost 1 patient intraoperatively, there were no late deaths (4% mortality).
19 patients (76%) are free of VT clinically, they have no persisting late
potentials or signs of ventricular irritability at programmed stimulation. 5
patients are under antiarrhythmic drugs, 1 patient has an antiarrhythmic
pacemaker.
We conclude that an electrophysiologically
guided approach improves the efficacy of the surgical treatment of VT
significantly in comparison to simple, "blind" aneurysmectomy.
*By invitation
18. Changes in Indications for Heart
Transplantation, An Additional Argument For the Preservation of the Recipient's
Diseased Heart
JACQUES G. LOSMAN*,
HARRY D. LEVINE*,
CHARLES D.
CAMPBELL*, ROBERT L. REPLOGLE
and CHRISTIAAN N.
BARNARD*
Chicago, Illinois
and Cape Town, South Africa
Heart transplantation (HT) one year (y)
survival improved since 1967 from ±30% to ±70%, 5 y survival is now ±50%. This
brought renewed interest in HT, now done in about 20 centers in 5 countries,
and increased confidence has widened the indication to patients (pt) less than
terminally ill, to restore quality of life. This trend is illustrated by the
Cape Town series, when 1967-74 pt [CT1 = 10 orthotopic HT (OHT)] are
compared to 1974-78 pt [CT2 = 20 heterotopic HT (HHT)]. CT2
pt are younger, m = 38.2±2.2 y than CT1, pt, m = 51.1±2.7
y [p<0.001], CT2 illness is shorter, m = 3.6 ± 0.7 y,
versus CT1 m = 6.6±1.4 y [p<0.019], and CT2 NYHA Class is
less, m = 3.45 ± 0.11 versus CT1, m = 3.9 ± 1.0,
[p<0.006]. The improved survival is linked to pt selection, progress in
management and switch to HHT, but not to progress in matching between donor (d)
and recipient (r). Since there is no means to predict tolerance of the d heart
(dh), HHT limits the risks from unforseeable mismatch. The retained r heart
(rh) is a build-in assist device, life saving when dh fails acutely at
surgery, during acute [3 pt] or chronic [2 pt] rejection. Had these pt been OHT
r, they would have died. Comparing the 10 oldest HHT r with CT1, no
difference in pre-HT parameters was found. However, HHT r survival was longer
during the critical post-HT period: at 3 months p<0.011, at 6 months
p<0.05. Larger series will separate effects of management progress from HHT
intrinsic advantages. Retaining the rh is logical, and brought few
complications. Survival of 38 HHT r was 74% at 6, 67% at 12 and 51% at 36
months, 85% of survivors are in NYHA Class 1. In pt less than desperate, but
who refuse to remain cripples, HHT eliminates the growing ethical problem of
removing a rh that may still support its owner.
*By invitation