WEDNESDAY MORNING,
APRIL 30,1980
8:30 A.M. Scientific Session - Continental
Ballroom
29. Clinical Durability of the (Hancock) Porcine
Xenograft Valve
PHILIP E. OVER*, D.
CRAIG MILLER*,
EDWARD B. STINSON*,
BRUCE A REITZ*,
RICARDO
MORENO-CABRAL*, and
NORMAN E. SHUMWAY,
Stanford, California
The principal feature which
remains to be completely defined in regard to the Hancock xenograft
bioprosthesis is long-term durability. As increasing numbers of bioprosthetic
valves are implanted, this characteristic assumes greater importance,
particularly since some investigators have recently advocated abandonment of
xenografts because of impaired function after 5 years (yrs). This report
provides extended data regarding valve durability derived from 1407 patients (707
aortic [AYR] and 700 mitral [MVR] replacements) who received Hancock
bioprostheses between 1971 and 1979; cumulative duration of follow-up was 1732
patient-years (pt-yrs) for AYR and 1843 pt-yrs for MVR, and maximum followup
was 8.4 yrs. One hundred seventy nine pts were followed for more than 5 yrs and
67 for more than 6 yrs. Valve failure was defined on the basis of the following
criteria: 1) development of a new regurgitant murmur 2) thrombotic valvular
occlusion 3) infective endocarditis resulting in reoperation or death 4)
hemodynamic valvular dysfunction confirmed by catheterization and resulting in
reoperation or death. Using these criteria 15 valve failures occurred in the
AVR cohort and 23 in the MVR cohort, yielding linearized occurrence rates of 0.9%/pt-yr
and 1.3%/pt-yr., respectively. Actuarial analysis revealed that 96 ± 1.2% (±
SEM) of AVR pts after 5 yrs and 90 ± 2.6% of MVR pts after 6 yrs were free of
valve failure. Primary tissue failure (defined by calcification or leaflet
disruption resulting in stenosis and/or regurgitation without antecedent
endocarditis) or valve thrombosis accounted for 5 of 15 AVR failures and 13 of
23 MVR failures, equivalent to linearized occurrence rates of 0.3%/ pt-yr and
0.7%/ pt-yr, respectively. Calculation by actuarial methods revealed that 98 ±
1% of AVR (at 5 yrs) and 92.5 ± 2.4% of MVR pts (at 6 yrs) were free of primary
tissue failure or valve thrombosis. The actuarially-calculated rate of valve
failure up to 5 yrs remains constant as a function of time for AVR pts; for MVR
pts there appears to be a slight acceleration in the rate of valve failure
after 5 yrs. In this extended experience the incidence of xenograft valve
failure 5 to 6 yrs postoperatively remains acceptably low and supports the
continued use of the xenograft bioprosthesis for cardiac valve replacement.
*By invitation
30. Risk-Benefit Analysis of Warfarin Therapy in
Hancock Mitral Valve Replacement
J. DONALD HILL,
LIZELLEN LA FOLLETTE*.
ROBERT J.
SZARNICKI*, G. JAMES A VERY, II*,
WILLIAM J. KERTH,
FRANK GERBODE,
and ROBERT RODVIEN*,
San Francisco, California
Porcine mitral valve bioprostheses have a low thromboembolic rate.
Controversy persists concerning whether warfarin lowers this rate further
without undue risk. In mid-1976 we changed from no systemic anticoag-ulation to
routine systemic anticoagulation begun on day 3. The purpose, therefore, of
this investigation was to analyze the thromboembolic and/or major bleeding
complications of 124 consecutive but nonrandomized patients who had only
Hancock mitral valve replacements between 9/74 and 6/79 treated with and
without anticoagulants. Four basic study groups were created: Group 1,
warfarin; Group 2, aspirin; Group 3, no anticoagulants; Group 4, warfarin and
aspirin. Group 5 combines Groups 1 and 4 (warfarin and warfarin and aspirin)
and Group 6 combines Groups 2 and 3 (aspirin and no antigoagulants).
|
Group
Therapy
|
1
Warfarin
|
2
Aspirin
|
3
No anti- coagulants
|
4
Warfarin+ Aspirin
|
5
Combined 1 + 4
|
6
Combined 2 + 3
|
|
No. of Patients
|
72
|
21
|
26
|
5
|
77
|
47
|
|
Mean follow-up (yr)
|
2.2
|
4.2
|
3.7
|
2.0
|
2.2
|
3.9
|
|
Patient years
|
158.2
|
87.8
|
96.7
|
9.9
|
168.1
|
184.4
|
|
Emboli
|
4
|
2
|
3
|
0
|
4
|
5
|
|
Emboli per 100 patient years
|
2.5
|
2.3
|
3.1
|
0.0
|
2.4
|
2.7
|
|
Major bleeding complications
|
9
|
1
|
0.0
|
0.0
|
9
|
1
|
|
Major bleeding per 100 patient yrs
|
5.7
|
1.1
|
0.0
|
0.0
|
5.4
|
0.5
|
The embolic rate was not significantly
different in any group (P = NS). There were no deaths from emboli in any group.
Group 1 (warfarin) resulted in significant major bleeding complications
(P<0.05), including one death. Bleeding was also increased in Group 5
(warfarin, and warfarin and aspirin) (P< 0.01).
Conclusions: There is no difference in the thromboembolic rate with or
without warfarin in patients with Hancock mitral valve prostheses. 2. Warfarin
significantly increases major bleeding complications in this clinical setting.
*By invitation
31. Year of Operation as a Risk Factor in the Late
Results of Valve Replacement
ALBERT STARR, GARY
L. GRUNKEMEIER*,
JOSEPH F. TEPLY* and
QUENTIN MacMANUS*,
Portland, Oregon
The actuarial thromboembolic rates of aortic and mitral noncloth-covered
caged-ball valves used during the second decade of cardiac valve replacement
are significantly lower than for the same prostheses implanted during the first
decade, as shown in the following table:
Model
|
Mitral
6120
|
Aortic
1200/60
|
|
Implant years
|
1965-72
|
1973-79
|
1965-72
|
1973-79
|
|
Number of patients
|
83
|
67
|
133
|
216
|
|
Maximum/mean follow-up (years)
|
14/8.4
|
5/1.8
|
13/8.8
|
6/1.9
|
|
Five year embolus-free rate ( ± SE)
|
69(± 6)%
|
96(± 4)%
|
78(± 4)%
|
93(± 2)%
|
|
P-value
|
p=.017
|
p=.004
|
Five year embolus-free rates for the composite-strut caged-ball,
Bjork-Shiley tilting disc and porcine xenograft valves all fall in the range of
from 88% to 91% for the mitral position and from 91% to 94% for the aortic.
Thus the standard noncloth-covered prosthesis, used during the current era, has
a thromboembolic risk as low as that reported with other concurrently utilized
valve substitutes. This striking reduction in thrombogenicity demonstrates that
the time frame of implantation must be considered when evaluating the results
of cardiac valve replacement.
*By invitation
32. Open Mitral Commissurotomy-A Modern Evaluation
WILLIAM L. HALSETH*,
DONALD P. ELLIOTT*,
E. LANCE WALKER* and
ELEANOR A. SMITH*,
Denver, Colorado
Sponsored by: Ben
Eiseman, Denver, Colorado
Familiarity with replacement of the mitral
valve (MVR) with prosthetic and tissue valves has dimmed awareness of the
usefulness of open mitral commissurotomy (OMC). This is a review of a 10-year
experience ending in December 1978 of 259 consecutive patients operated upon
with a clinical diagnosis of mitral stenosis. MVR was necessary in 62 patients
(24%), primarily because of severe deformity of valvular and subvalvular
structures. No closed commissuortomies were performed-an operation now
considered passe.
Of the 197 OMC, 12 had additional cardiac
procedures. Of the 3 patients who died (1.52%), two were operated upon as
emergencies because of rapidly progressive cardiac failure.
Followup was obtained on 191/197 (91%)of
the OMC patients. Late mortality was 9%(18 patients) of whom 14 were
cardiac related. 76% of patients (146) had at least one category New York Heart
Association Class improvement following OMC. Fourteen (7%) of the 191 OMC
patients had subsequent MVR at times varying from 2-92 months (mean 41.6
months). Ten year survival for the 191 OMC patients was 81%.
Summary and Conclusions:
(1) Open mitral commissurotomy (OMC) was
performed in 197 of 259 patients with the clinical diagnosis of mitral
stenosis. Of these, 81% survived 10 years, and 14 (7%) subsequently required
valve replacement. (2) OMC is the operation of first choice for patients with
the clinical diagnosis of mitral stenosis. The main indication for proceeding
to MVR at the first operation is severe valve deformity, which prevents
successful commissurotomy.
(3) There will be no need for valve
replacement in 93% of patients following OMC, 76% of whom will experience
measurable and lasting functional benefit from open commissurotomy alone.
(4) This clinical experience emphasizes that
open commissurotomy rather than valve replacement is the best initial treatment
for most patients with mitral stenosis.
*By invitation
33. Is Tricuspid Valve Repair Necessary?
CARLOS M. G. DURAN,
JOSEL. POMAR*,
THIERRY COLMAN*, ALVARO
FIGUEROA*
JOSE M. REVUELTA*, and JOSE L. UBAGO*,
Santander, Spain
In an attempt to clarify the still confusing
indications for tricuspid surgery, a group of 150 patients (pts) has been
studied. Selection was made according to the following criteria 1) All had
preoperative significant tricuspid disease and 2) pre and postoperative right
and left catheterization including biventriculography was available. It has
been previously proven in our laboratory, by correlating the hemodynamic and
surgical findings, that our technique of right ventriculography is highly
reliable in the diagnosis of tricuspid insufficiency (TI) and whether it is an
organic or functional lesion. 123 (82%)pts were recatheterized as part
of a routine follow up study and 27 (18%) for clinical deterioration. 89 had an
associated mitral and 61 mitral and aortic disease. After left side repair, 119
pts underwent tricuspid surgery (group A). In 31 pts the tricuspid valve was
not repaired (group B).
In group A, 64 (54%) had one or more tricuspid
commissures ("organic") and the remainder 55 were classified as "functional".
Tricuspid valve repair includes 73 ring annuloplasties, 42 commissurotomies and
annulo-plasties and 4 commissurotomies. Postoperative gradients averaging 2.8
mm Hg (± 1.6) were found in 31% of the pts with functional and in 44% of those
with organic TI. Those pts with tricuspid gradients averaged a cardiac index
(CI) of 3.2 L/min/m2 and those without gradients 2.8 (p<0.01).
Significant residual TI was found in 10 functional and 26 organic valves.
Clinically, 85% were in Functional Class I despite their small residual
gradients and TI. Further analysis of the hemodynamic data of this group of pts
showed that the postoperative CI was directly related to the adequacy of the left
side repair and to the residual pulmonary resistances independently of whether
residual TI was present or not. These facts seem to imply that the associated
tricuspid repair is at best unnecessary. However, when measuring right
ventricular volumes it was observed a postoperative increase of 9.3% in those
pts with persistent TI and a 37% decrease in those with tricuspid competence.
In group B, all 14 pts with organic disease
showed residual TI. 8 pts out of the 17 with functional TI had no regurgitation
concomitant with a significant decrease in pulmonary resistances. In the
remainder 9 pts the TI persisted.
Based on these data that emphasize the need
for a correct left side repair, our present attitude towards tricuspid repair
is: 1) Functional TI can only be ignored in pts with predictable significant
reduction in pulmonary resistances, 2) Organic disease must be repaired.
INTERMISSION - 45
MINUTES
VISIT EXHIBITS
*By invitation
34. Sternal Wound Complication Management And
Results
CYRUS SERRY*,
PHYLLIS C. BLECK*, HUSHANG JAVID,
JAMES A. HUNTER,
MARSHALL D. GOLDIN*,
GIACOMO A. DELARIA*,
and HASSAN NAJAFI,
Chicago, Illinois
Records of 4,125 patients who underwent
sternotomy for cardiac surgery were reviewed to determine the incidence of
sternal wound complications (1.8%), including wound drainage, skin separation,
unstable sternum, and sternal dehiscence with or without infection. Septicemia
and mediastinal abcesses were found in all 19 patients who expired.
Based on findings, local treatment (incision
and drainage of skin and subcutaneous tissue with frequent change of dressing
or irrigation (Method A) is recommended for (1) serosanguineous drainage, (2)
patients with stable sternums and superficial infection, but no systemic
reaction. However, surgical debridement and closure followed by mediastinal
irrigation via drainage tubes with 0.5% povidone iodine solution (Method B) is
recommended for (1) draining, unstable sternums, (2) wound infections involving
the retrosternal space and (3) wound infections causing systemic reactions
unresponsive to Method A.
It was found that none of the eight patients
in the latter group died when managed by Method B, and only one developed
recurrent infection. In contrast, from 28 patients of the latter group not
treated with Method B, 11 died of infection related causes and 13 returned with
recurrent infection.
35. Fulminating Non-Cardiogenic Pulmonary Edema-A
Newly Recognized Hazard During Cardiac Operations
ALFRED T. CULLIFORD,* STEPHEN THOMAS* and
FRANK C. SPENCER,
New York, New York
In the past 24 months, four patients have been
successfully treated for fulminating pulmonary edema following coronary bypass
operations. In each patient, the fulminating edema began within 30-60 minutes
after infusion of blood products, usually fresh-frozen plasma, suggesting an
allergic mechanism. Copious frothy fluid poured from the endotracheal tube,
with hypoxia and respiratory acidosis. Left atrial pressure was only 5.0-10
mm., excluding left ventricular failure; and the electrocardiogram and CPK
isoenzymes excluded myocardial infarction. The albumin content of the fluid was
significantly elevated, suggesting an exudate rather than a transudate.
Three postoperative patients were promptly
reoperated upon, and in one of these, the sternum could not be closed for 72
hours because stiff, distended lungs compressed the heart. Treatment consisted
of intravenous prednisolone 2.0-3.0 gms., positive pressure ventilation,
diuretics and albumin (in the last two patients).
It was dramatic that within 72 hours this
near-lethal condition subsided completely, with no further cardiac or pulmonary
complications.
The allergic mechanism is still unclear, but
the effectiveness of immediate treatment, as described, prompts this early
report. Undoubtedly, patients have died in past years with the erroneous
diagnosis of fulminating cardiac failure or "pump lung." This rare condition is
readily recognized when massive pulmonary edema develops without signs of left
ventricular failure-an occurrence which is easily discerned in a properly
monitored patient.
*By invitation
36. Immediate Coronary Artery Bypass for Acute
Evolving Myocardial Infarction (AEMI)
RALPH BERG, JR.,
SAMUEL L. SELINGER*,
RONALD P. GRUNWALD* and
WILLIAM P. O'GRADY*,
Spokane, Washington
212 consecutive patients (March 1971-April 1979) all had infarction
syndrome, electrocardiographic, coronary angiographic, ventriculographic and
retrospective enzyme changes consistent with AEMI. In 212 AEMI patients, means
age 55.8 years (R = 28-79), onset of CAB surgery was less than six hours,
yielding three surgical deaths for a 1.7% mortality. Conversely, medical
therapy in 200 consecutive AEMI patients, mean age 53.2 years (R = 40-65)
resulted in 23 deaths giving in-hospital mortality (IHM) of 11.5% plus first
year mortality of 14%. Pre and post-operative enzyme and EKG values, age, sex
and coronary artery involvement are presented. Angiograms done an average of
7.9 months post-op of 97 grafts to the infarcting areas revealed 95 patent
(92%). Ejection fractions were normal, unchanged or improved in 86%. Two small
ventricular aneurysms were noted. Follow-up of 200 patients revealed three
deaths within the first year (1.8%). 26 patients had mild angina. Quality of
life was the same or improved in 196. In summary, AEMI patients must have CAB
early in the syndrome. Surgical results are far superior to medical therapy:
Medical IHM (11.5%) + first year mortality (14%) = 25.5%. Surgical IHM (1.7%) +
first year mortality (1.8%) = 3.5%.
*By invitation
37. Multivariate Discriminant Analysis of Clinical
and Angiographic Predictor of Coronary Surgery Mortality
J. WARD KENNEDY*,
GEORGE KAISER, LLOYD FISHER*,
WILLIAM O. MYERS, GERARD MUDD* and
THOMAS J. RYAN*,
Seattle, Washington; St. Louis, Missouri
CASS is a large multi-institutional study of
the medical and surgical treatment of coronary artery disease. Fifteen
cooperating institutes have operated on 7,122 patients from August, 1975
through December, 1978. The in hospital operative mortality (OM) was 2.89%. In
an effort to better understand the clinical and angiographic characteristics
predictive of OM, we have done a multivariate discriminant analysis of
variables associated with OM.
Numersou clinical and angiographic variables
were selected from the CASS data file and evaluated in a univariate manner for
their relationship ot OM. Twenty-two of these variables were then selected for
multivariate discriminant analysis. Clinical variables of most value were age,
sex, heart size, and symptoms, signs, or treatment for congestive heart
failure. Angiographic variables of importance included EF, left ventricular
wall motion abnormalties, and the severity of left main coronary disease.
Multivariate discriminant analysis resulted in
the selection of eight variables that contained the most predictive information
as listed below.
|
Variable
|
F
Statistic
|
|
Congestive Heart
Failure Score
|
73.3
|
|
Age
|
37.5
|
|
Left Main Coronary
Stenosis ≥ 90%
|
24.8
|
|
Left Ventricular
Wall Motion Score
|
22.9
|
|
Female Sex
|
21.4
|
|
Heart Enlargement
by Chest X-Ray
|
17.9
|
|
Pulmonary Rales
|
12.0
|
|
Left Ventricular
Dilitation by Angiography
|
9.4
|
The strong association of OM with advanced age, female sex and variables
associated with left ventricular dysfunction is clear. The risk of OM for an
individual patient may be estimated with the use of these eight clinical and
angiographic characteristics.
*By invitation
38. Doppler Velocity Measurements of Coronary
Flow: A Noninvasive Intraoperative Guide to Hemodynamically Significant Lesions
CREIGHTON B. WRIGHT,
DONALD B. DOTY,
MELVIN L. MARCUS*,
and CHARLES L. EASTHAM*,
Iowa City, Iowa
Although angiography is in general a reliable
guide to the coronary vessels which should by bypassed in individuals with
angina pectoris, some lesions escape accurate preoperative assessment. This leaves
the surgeon with the dilemma of whether to bypass all visible vessels or to
risk not bypassing significant disease.
Utilizing the miniaturized pulsed single
crystal Doppler velocity probe and technique developed at the University of
Iowa Hospitals and Clinics to measure phasic coronary velocity, the hemodynamic
significance of experimental and clinical coronary stenoses can be assessed
readily. No dissection of the vessels is required. The probe is held in place
over the coronary vessel with a small suction cup. The velocity traces are
linearly related to electromagnetic blood flow (R = 0.98). Reactive hyperemia
curves obtained with 20 second occlusions demonstrate reproducibly the vessels
with hemo-dynamically significant stenoses.
This technique has been used in over 50
patients with a variety of anatomic lesions. In 6 recent patients in which the
degree of stenosis of a vessel was disputed or thought to be less than 50%, the
use of the Doppler probe and a 20 second reactive hyperemia curve allowed accurate
and immediate assessment of the need for bypass.
It is the purpose of this presentation to
describe this new unique technique, its benefits, limitations, and overall
accuracy.
Adjournment
1:00 P.M. Cardiothoracic
Residents' Luncheon
Continental Ballrooms 8
& 9
*By invitation