WEDNESDAY MORNING, MAY 10,1978
8:30 A.M. Scientific Sessions - Ballroom
27. Long Term
Clinical and Hemodynamic Evaluation of the Ionescu-Shiley Pericardial
Xenograft, Braunwald-Cutter and Bjork-Shiley Prostheses in the Mitral Position
ANAND P. TANDON* and
MARIAN I. IONESCU*, Leeds, England
Sponsored by Harris
B. Shumacker, Indianapolis, Indiana
Since March 1971, single mitral valve replacement
was performed in 220 patients. One hundred twenty-six received glutaraldehyde
stabilized Pericardial Xenografts (PX), 52 Braunwald-Cutter (BC) and 42
Bjork-Shiley (BS) prostheses. No attempt was made at randomization. Only
patients with BC and BS prostheses were permanently anticoagulated. Hemodynamic
studies were performed in 29 patients with PX and in 6 each with BC and BS
prostheses at mean periods of 40.2,43.0 and 22.7 months postop respectively.
The essential data are summarized below:
|
|
PX
|
BC
|
BS
|
|
Follow-up
(months) - total
|
3270
|
1947
|
1282
|
|
- range
|
6-83
|
25-62
|
7.82
|
|
Late mortality %
|
4.8
|
15.4
|
11.9
|
|
Actuarial survival rate %
|
89.0 ± 9.3
|
41.7 ± 22.9
|
81.9 ± 12.8
|
|
Actuarial thromboembolism
free rate %
|
95.8 ± 2.1
|
93.2 ± 5.3
|
84.8 ± 8.4
|
|
Thromboemboli per 100patient
years
|
1.46
|
1.8
|
4.7
|
|
Mean diastolic gradient (mm
Hg)
|
|
-
rest
|
6.4
|
8.3
|
6.3
|
|
-
exercise
|
15.3
|
18.1
|
17.6
|
|
Calculated valve area (cm2)
|
|
-
rest
|
2.0
|
1.6
|
1.8
|
|
-
exercise
|
2.3
|
1.7
|
2.2
|
|
Of the late deaths in the BC
group 62% were valve related.
|
Detailed
laboratory studies showed no hemolysis in patients with PX and mild red cell
destruction in patients with BC and BS prostheses.
The
Ionescu-Shiley Pericardial Xenograft in the mitral position has proved to be
durable, least thrombogenic without anticoagulants and hemodynamically sound.
There was no
significant difference, statistically, between the data recorded from the three
groups of patients except for the survival rate of patients with pericardial
xenografts and Braunwald-Cutter prostheses.
*By invitation
28. In Vitro Hydrodynamic Performance of Mitral
Valve Prostheses at High Flow Rates
S. GABBAY*, D.
McQUEEN*, E. L. YELLIN*, R. M. BECKER*
and R. W. M. FRATER,
New York, New York
The in vitro hydrodynamic characteristics of 7
currently available mitral prostheses were compared in a pulse duplicator at
high-output steady and pulsatile flow with variable stroke volume and pulse
rate. Three different mounting diameters (small, medium, large) of each of the
following prostheses were studied: Starr-Edwards (SE), Beall (BE),
Ionescu-Shiley (IS), Cooley-Cutter (CC), Hancock (H), Bjork-Shiley (BS),
Lillehei-Kaster (LK). Effective orifice areas were computed using hydraulic
formulas and a performance index (PI), defined as the ratio of effective area
to mounting area, was calculated. The results for medium and large size valves
in pulsatile flow are tabulated below:
|
|
MEDIUM
|
LARGE
|
|
|
Mount.
|
Mount.
|
Eff.
|
|
Press
|
Mount.
|
Mount.
|
Eff.
|
|
Press
|
|
|
Diam.
|
Area
|
Area
|
|
Drop
|
Diam.
|
Area
|
Area
|
|
Drop
|
|
Valve
|
mm
|
cm2
|
cm2
|
PI**
|
mmHg
|
mm
|
cm2
|
cm2
|
PI**
|
mmHg
|
|
SE
|
26
|
5.31
|
1.56
|
0.29
|
16.5
|
20
|
7.07
|
1.92
|
0.27
|
11.3
|
|
BE
|
--
|
--
|
--
|
--
|
--
|
29.2
|
6.70
|
2.00
|
0.30
|
9.8
|
|
IS
|
25
|
4.91
|
1.92
|
0.39
|
11.1
|
29
|
6.61
|
2.96
|
0.45
|
4.8
|
|
CC
|
24
|
4.52
|
2.08
|
0.46
|
9.5
|
30
|
7.07
|
2.66
|
0.38
|
5.8
|
|
H
|
25.6
|
5.15
|
1.64
|
0.32
|
15.3
|
29
|
6.61
|
1.98
|
0.30
|
10.3
|
|
BS
|
25
|
4.91
|
2.16
|
0.44
|
9.0
|
29
|
6.61
|
3.01
|
0.46
|
4.7
|
|
LK
|
25
|
4.91
|
1.54
|
0.31
|
17.6
|
29
|
6.61
|
2.67
|
0.40
|
5.8
|
|
** Based on all flow rates
(of 1-11 L/min) and a range of rates from 60-125 /min.
Mean gradient at a
pulsatile flow rate of 9 L/min.
Not studied.
|
In all valves, effective orifice areas are less
than 50% of mounting area and 75% of measured orifice area. At pulsatile flow
rates of 9 L/min (comparable to mild to moderate exercise) all valves are
mildly to severely stenotic. Among mechanical valves the BS has the least
resistance to flow and the SE the most. Of the biological valves the IS is less
resistant to flow than the H and only slightly more resistant than
the BS.
Assuming a satisfactory durability and given the
favorable characteristics of tissue valves, other than hemodynamic performance,
the Ionescu-Shiley heterograft valve appears to be the best mitral prosthesis
currently available.
*By invitation
29. Non-Cloth-Covered Caged-Ball Prostheses: The
Second Decade
ALBERT STARR, GARY
L. GRUNKEMEIER*,
LOUIS E. LAMBERT*,
DAVID R. THOMAS*and
EDWARD A. LEFRAK*,
Portland, Oregon
This report is concerned with results achieved
using current-model non-cloth-covered caged-ball valves since 1965. The data
are analyzed in a comparative fashion with other series employing a variety of
prostheses.
The actuarial
late survival rates with the bare-strut ball valves were the same as those
achieved with all mechanical and tissue valves, i.e., 80% at 5 years and 60% at
10 years after surgery. There were no significant differences in the
hemodynamic effects with any contemporary prostheses. Mean systolic gradients
after aortic valve replacement ranged between 8 and 20 mmHg with calculated
orifice areas of 1.5 to 2.2 cm2. Following mitral replacement, mean
diastolic gradients varied between 3 and 8 mmHg at rest with orifice areas of
1.9 to 2.5 cm2. An analysis of comparative thromboembolic rates
failed to show a difference of significant magnitude (mitral 3 - 6%/year,
aortic 1.5 - 5%/year). There was however a difference in the incidence of
thrombotic catastrophic failure. After mitral replacement in patients receiving
anti-coagulation, the rate of thrombosis with the caged-ball valve was 0.5 ±
.3%/year versus 2.5 ± .7%/year with the Bjork-Shiley valve.
With the
non-cloth-covered caged-ball aortic valves, in 182 patients followed for 855
patient-years (mean 4.7 years), there were no cases of thrombotic stenosis.
Actuarial data are not available on the tilting disc valves but this
complication has been frequently reported. Structural failures have not been
seen with the Model 1200/1260 Starr-Edwards aortic prostheses, but have already
appeared with glutaraldehyde-preserved porcine xenografts.
These features
justify the continued use of the non-cloth-covered ball valve prosthesis as a
device whose clinical performance has not been surpassed by any current
mechanical valves.
*By invitation
30. Prosthetic Valve Endocarditis: A Comparison of
Hetero-graft Tissue Valves and Mechanical Valves
STEPHEN J. ROSSITER
*, EDWARD B. STINSON*, PHILIP E. OYER*,
D. CRAIG MILLER *,
JAY N. SCHAPIRA, RANDOLPH P. MARTIN*
and NORMAN E.
SHUMWAY, Stanford, California
Despite decreasing incidence, prosthetic valve
endocarditis (PVE) remains a highly lethal condition, with reported overall
mortality rates of 50-60%. Some authors have suggested that gluteraldehyde
preserved heterografts (HET) might be more resistant to infection or to certain
of its complications than mechanical prosthetic valves.
This study
reviewed 2,184 patients who underwent prosthetic valve replacement from 1963 to
1977, with a total follow-up of 7,123 patient-years. Eight-hundred and
thirty-seven patients with Hancock HET valves - 384 aortic valves (HET AYR) and
453 mitral valves (HET AVR) were compared with 1,347 patients with mechanical
Starr-Edwards valves (SE) - 779 aortic valves (SE AVR) and 568 mitral valves
(SE MVR). PVE occurred in 51 patients, 9 early (<2 months post-operatively)
and 42 late (>2 months postoperatively). Linearized rates of endocarditis
(percent per patient-year) for the various groups were HET AVR 2.2%, HET MVR
0.1% (p<0.01); SE AVR 2.7%, SE MVR 0.4% (p<0.01). Differences between HET
and SE groups are not significant but the higher incidence of PVE after AVR, as
compared to MVR, is significant. Five of 16 (31%) HET patients and 13 of 35
(37%) of SE patients with PVE died (N.S.). In contrast to some studies, early
PVE mortality (5/9 = 55%) was not significantly worse than late PVE mortality
(13/42) = 31%). Additionally, comparison of HET and SE group mortality rates
failed to reveal statistically significant differences upon analyzing results
of medical versus surgical treatment or early versus late endocarditis. There
was no significant difference between the two valves in distribution of types
of infecting organisms (no Myco-bacterial infections were encountered). The
higher incidence of HET valves sustaining early endocarditis (6/16) as compared
to SE Valves (3/35) (p<0.05) remains unexplained.
Although
heterograft valves have certain advantages compared to mechanical valves,
resistance to endocarditis, pathological behavior once sustaining PVE, survival
rates with PVE, and curability with medical treatment are similar. Diagnostic
aids, including ultrasonic sector scanning, and therapeutic recommendations are
discussed.
INTERMISSION -
VISIT EXHIBITS
*By invitation
31. The Surgical Anatomy of Kent Bundles Based on
Electrophysiologic Mapping and Surgical Exploration
WILL C. SEALY, JOHN
J. GALLAGHER*and
EDWARD L. C.
PRITCHETT*, Durham, North Carolina
The development of a reliable method for the
interruption of Kent Bundles in all locations about the atrioventricular
junction of the heart has been hampered by the paucity of anatomic descriptions
of the pathways and by their location in areas difficult to expose and
unfamiliar to the surgeon. After a review of the 25 reported descriptions, it
was evident that they were inadequate to explain many of the findings we had
noted in the surface mapping and surgical exploration of 95 patients with Kent
Bundles. In this report we will correlate the known anatomic facts with our
deductions based on our observations at surgery. This has led to the
development of satisfactory operative procedures for the interruption of Kent
Bundles in the free wall of both ventricles and in the septal areas as shown by
our success in 52 of our last 55 patients. The following conclusions concerning
the location of Kent Bundles have been made:
1. Kent Bundles can occur anywhere that there is continuity of the
atrium and ventricle.
2. More than one Kent Bundle may be present.
3. Kent Bundles may be found in the
pericoronary fat from the sub-epicardial area to the annulus fibrosus.
4. Septal pathways may be adjacent to the AV
node-His system, anterior to the atrial septum, or posterior at anyplace
beginning at the insertion of the atrial septum into the right fibrous trigone
and going to the epicardium over the crux.
5. Access to septal pathways has been
facilitated-by entering from the right atrium the triangular space that is
beneath the atrial septum and on top of the ventricular septum.
6. The key to the successful interruption of a
Kent Bundle is the wide dissection of the fat away from the ventricle and the
atrium.
*By invitation
32. Composite Replacement of the Aortic Valve and
Ascending Aorta
JOHN E. MAYER, JR.
*, W. G. LINDSAY*, Y. WANG*,
C. JORGENSON* and D.
M. NICOLOFF, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Cystic medial necrosis primarily affects the
ascending aorta resulting in aneurysm formation and secondary aortic
insufficiency. Since the entire ascending aorta and sinuses of valsalva are
involved, total correction should involve replacement of the aorta from the
annulus to the innominate artery takeoff. A composite graft with an
incorporated aortic prosthesis and re-implantation of the coronary artery ostia
into the graft provides a method for correction. Fifteen (15) patients
underwent this procedure between January, 1973 and December, 1976. Seven were
Class II, six were Class III and one was operated upon emergently for acute
dissection. The procedure consisted of sewing a Lillehei-Kaster aortic
prosthesis into one end of a 30 or 35 mm. woven Dacron graft, and then suturing
the composite graft to the annulus. The graft extended to just proximal to the
innominate in 14 cases, and included the aortic arch in one case. One patient
had concomitant mitral valve replacement. The coronary ostia were sewn into the
sides of the graft except in one patient who had two saphenous vein coronary
bypass grafts. None of the patients required reoperation for excessive
postoperative bleeding. There was one early post-operative death (4 days)
(6.6%) from redissection of the right coronary artery and one late death (5
months) from left ventricular failure. Ten patients had repeat catheterization
6-12 months after surgery. There were no coronary ostial stenoses, but one
pseudoaneurysm developed secondary to suture line separation at left coronary
ostia requiring re-operation. One small asymptomatic pseudoaneurysm occurred at
the distal suture line and has not required re-operation. There were no aortic
paravalvular leaks. The maximal gradient across the valve prosthesis was 10
mmHg in the five patients measured. All surviving patients are Class I or II
with follow-up of 7 to 51 months. There has been one questionable episode of
embolism which resolved. This technique of composite replacement of the aortic
valve and ascending aorta can be accomplished with a low mortality, low
incidence of intra- and post-operative bleeding and with satisfactory long-term
results in patients with cystic medial necrosis of the aortic root.
*By invitation
33. The Natural History of Saccular Aneurysms of the
Left Ventricle
P. GRONDIN, L.
CAMPEAU*, O. BICAL*,
P. DONZEAU-GOUGE*,
J. G. KRETZ*and R. PETITCLERC*,
Montreal, Quebec,
Canada and Paris, France
The natural history of left ventricular aneurysms
is poorly known. Most studies are retrospective and based on autopsy cases.
Forty consecutive patients having a true saccular aneurysm demonstrated by
ventriculography, and who were not, for one reason or another, submitted to
surgery, have been followed for a mean period of 6 years and 3 months. Only
aneurysms showing an obvious diastolic bulge with a systolic paradoxical motion
were retained. These patients were divided in two groups; group one
representing patients who, at the time of diagnosis, had little or no symptoms
and group two, those having symptoms.
The clinical course differs with the group: the
functional status of patients in group one remaining satisfactory. Arrhythmias
are encountered in 35% and thrombo-embolic episodes in 17.5% of all patients.
Overall survival is satisfactory: 87% at one year and 80% at seven years.
Mortality is however elevated (60%) in patients having ventricular
extra-systoles at their first examination. Prognosis is influenced clinically,
by the presence or absence of symptoms at the time of diagnosis, and
anatomically, by the presence of an asynergic area adjacent to the aneurysm and
by the extension, on the L.V. angiogram, of both the aneurysm and the asynergic
area.
*By invitation
34. Techniques and Results of Ventricular
Aneurysmectomy with Emphasis on Antero-Septal Repair
WILLIAM E. WALKER*,
WILLIAM S. STONEY,
WILLIAM C. ALFORD,
GEORGE R. BURRUS*,
ROBERT A. FRIST*,
DAVID M. GLASSFORD*and
CLARENCE S. THOMAS*,
Nashville, Tennessee
Over the past 9 years, 175 patients have undergone
ventricular aneurysmectomy. Male/female ratio was 4:1, average age was 56 years
(range 30 to 74). One hundred forty-six or 83% had concomitant coronary artery
bypass (CAP), with an average of 1.8 grafts per patient. Forty-five patients
(26%) underwent simple excisions of anterior, apical, or lateral wall
aneurysms. One hundred fifteen patients (66%) underwent "antero-septal repair"
where the lateral margin of the incised ventricular wall was sutured down to
the posterior part of the inter-ventricular septum, to exclude the
non-contracting septal myocardium from the circumference of the left ventricle.
Fifteen patients (8%) had excision of an inferior wall aneurysm. Fifty patients
undergoing antero-septal repair had postoperative ventriculography to assess
changes in ejection fraction, akinetic volume, and end-diastolic volume.
There were 15 hospital deaths for an early
mortality of 8.5%. Advanced age was not a factor in early mortality (3 of 32
patients between 65 and 74 years old died) nor did age affect long-term
survival. Overall, adjuvant CAB did not affect early mortality nor long-term
survival, but none of 20 patients undergoing aneurysmectomy without CAB in the
past 6 years died. Three patients were moribund when operated upon, 1 survived.
Six patients required intra-aortic balloon support for an average of 4 days,
with 4 survivors. Actuarial survivals (b stand, devn.) were 80±4% and 62±5% for
the whole group at 2 and 5 years respectively. Despite being slightly older,
the women fared better with 70±6% vs. 58±5% survival at 5 years (p less than
0.01). Heart failure following recent myocardial infarction did not preclude a
good result, in fact these patients did very well. Three patients also had
closure of a VSD, and all survived. Actuarial 5-year survival following
antero-septal repair was 65±5%. There was a distinct group of patients with
very large aneurysms but with good contraction of the rest of the ventricle who
had an excellent result. Postoperative ventriculography confirmed the return
towards more normal hemodynamics following antero-septal repair.
Good results attend an aggressive approach to
ventricular aneurysmectomy. Suitable vessels should be bypassed. Satisfactory
results can be attained with the "bad" ventricle. Antero-septal repair is the
optimal approach to the "typical" aneurysm.
*By invitation