TUESDAY AFTERNOON, APRIL 19, 1977
2:00 P.M. Scientific Session Grand Ballroom
19. Cricopharyngeal
Myotomy as a Method of Treating Pharyngoesophageal Dysphagia Secondary to
Gastro-esophageal Reflux
R. D. HENDERSON and G. MARRY ATT*,
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Food obstruction at the Cricopharyngeal level
(Pharyngoesophageal dysphagia) is a common symptom of gastroesophageal reflux
(51.3% of 1000 consecutive patients). In selected patients, Cricopharyngeal
myotomy is effective in symptom relief. We have used myotomy in patients whose
only symptom was dysphagia (2); and in patients too debilitated for major
surgery (5);and in patients with persistent pharyngoesophageal
dysphagia following hiatal hernia repair (12 out of 650).
All were investigated by barium esophagramme, endoscopy
and manometry. 5 of 19 showed radiologic aspiration of barium. High speed
manometric tracing showed intermittent Cricopharyngeal inco-ordination in the 6
consecutive patients most recently studied. This finding of incoordination has
been shown to be present in 38 patients with reflux and in all with major
Cricopharyngeal symptoms.
Myotomy was effective in relieving symptoms in both
patients with this as their only reflux symptom and in the 5 patients too
debilitated for major surgery. Good symptomatic improvement was obtained in 9
of 12 with persistent dysphagia following hernia repair, but in 3 relief was
partial with persistent symptoms being secondary to distal esophageal
obstruction.
Investigation is necessary to exclude other causes of
dysphagia. However, with careful selection, myotomy has proved to be an
effective method of treatment.
*By invitation
20. Complications and Failings of the Combined
Collis-Belsey Operation
MARK B. ORRINGER* and HERBERT SLOAN,
Ann Arbor, Michigan
In the past 3 years, the Collis-Belsey operation has
been performed in 82 patients. Thirty-three of these patients (40%) had
undergone one or more previous operations at the esophagogastric junction;
transthoracic (22) or transab-dominal (18) hiatal hernia repair; vagotomy (11);
esophagomyotomy (5); or repair of an esophageal perforation (2).
In 4 of 15 patients, the combination of an
esophagomyotomy and the Collis-Belsey reconstruction resulted in postoperative
dysphagia which has required either chronic dilation (2) or esophagectomy and
colonic interposition (2). In 2 patients who had had previous hiatal hernia
repairs, mobilization of the extensively inflammed distal esophagus resulted in
delayed perforation from a localized area of esophageal necrosis; both healed
primarily following closure and reinforcement of the suture line with a
pedicled intercostal muscle flap. One patient sustained an esophageal
perforation during per-oral dilation of an esophageal stricture; attempted
closure immediately at the time of the Collis-Belsey procedure failed and
resulted in a chronic esophago-pleural-cutaneous fistula. A gastric fistula
developed in 2 of 3 patients who required splenectomy because of
intraopera-tive injury to the spleen; this closed spontaneously in 1 patient,
but eventually resulted in the death of the other.
To date, 68 patients have had postoperative follow-up
interviews and esophageal manometrics and acid reflux testing after 2-24 months
(average 8.7 months). Clinically, 60 (88%) have had excellent or good control
of gastroesophageal reflux, 3 have mild reflux but are greatly improved, and 5
have moderate to severe symptoms. With an intraesophageal pH electrode,
however, moderate to severe gastroesophageal reflux has been detected in 17
patients (25%), 9 of whom emphatically deny symptoms of reflux, and 8 of whom
have definite recurrent symptoms.
These data refute the concern expressed by others that
ischemic necrosis of the gastroplasty tube in patients who have had prior
operations at the esophagogastric junction is a frequent complication. They
suggest, however, that the Collis-Belsey operation is not the best choice of an
antireflux procedure when concomittant esophagomyotomy is required, and that
the recent enthusiasm for the combined Collis-Belsey operation should be
tempered by a cautious assessment of its long-term results.
*By invitation
21. Diffuse Spasm of the Esophagus: Clinical,
Manometric and Surgical Consideration
HOWARD K. LEONARDI*, JOHN A. SHEA* and
F. HENRY ELLIS, JR., Boston, Massachusetts
Concern regarding the development of gastroesophageal
reflux after extended esophagomyotomy for diffuse spasm of the esophagus (DSE)
has influenced some to complicate the operation by adding a Collis-Belsey
gastroplasty. Since we believe that a properly performed esophagomyotomy as
proposed originally by one of us (FHE) relieves the symptoms in the majority of
patients with DSE without the need for ancillary procedures, we have reviewed
the clinical, manometric and surgical findings in 11 recent cases to shed
further light on the controversy.
Substernal pain was the characteristic symptom in three
of the 11. Dysphagia of variable degree was present in nine. Four patients had
a small sliding esophageal hiatus hernia and two an epiphrenic diverticulum.
Preoperative manometry determined the length of the myotomy and the lower
esophageal sphincter (LES) was spared when normal. One patient whose lower
sphincter was included in the myotomy developed medically manageable
gastroesophageal reflux.
Esophageal
manometry was performed in all patients. Hie disease involved the lower
one-third of the esophagus in two, lower one-half in three and lower two-thirds
in four. Themean maximum deglutitive pressure in the diseased area was
70 mm. Hg. The contractions were non-peristaltic, repetitive and spontaneous in
most. Postoperative manometry in nine patients revealed a reduction in
deglutitive pressures from a mean of 70 mm. Hg. to 20 mm. Hg. The mean LES
pressure postoperatively was 13 mm. Hg. and was sufficient to prevent reflux in
all but one patient.
*By invitation
22. Intra-Operative and Post-Operative Esophageal
Mano-metric Findings with Collis Gastroplasty and Belsey Hiatus Hernia Repair
for Gastro-Esophageal Reflux
J. D. COOPER*, S. GILL*, J. M. NELEMS* and F. G. PEARSON,
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
The combination of a
Collis gastroplasty with a Belsey Mark IV fundoplication has proven clinically
effective in the management of certain patients with complications of
gastroesophageal reflux. The present study measured the effect of gastroplasty
and Belsey repair on intraluminal pressure changes in the gastroplasty and
lower esophagus. Manometric studies were performed on 8 patients who had
gastroplasty and Belsey repair for reflux esophagitis. Measurements were
performed using the MP-3 catheter which consists of 3 miniature pressure
transducers spaced 5 cms. apart. Manometric studies were performed
pre-operatively, intra-operatively and post-operatively. Intra-operatively the
precise location of the tranducers could be determined by palpation through the
wall of the stomach and esophagus. Post-operative studies were done with the
aid of a fluoroscope so the transducer could be identified in relationship to
the gastroplasty segment (which had been marked with radio-opaque clips at the
time of surgery). At the time of operation the lower esophageal sphincter area
was located manometrically and tagged with a marking suture. After creation of
a 5 cm. gastroplasty tube, and again after completion of fundoplication, the
transducers were advanced into the stomach and gradually withdrawn into the
esophagus for pressure recordings. In each case the gastroplasty segment was
immediately found to function as a high pressure zone. The pressure in this
zone further increased following the fundoplication and this pressure could be
diminished with intravenous Buscopan and augmented with intravenous
Pentagastrin. The original, previously marked, lower esophageal sphincter was
found in most instances to be included in the upper segment of the gastroplasty
tube, but the entire length of the gastroplasty tube functioned as a high
pressure zone and pressures in the tube were considerably higher than those
originally present in the lower sphincter. The following Table gives the average
pressures recorded in the eight patients:
|
|
Pre-Operative
|
prior to gastroplasty
|
Intra-Operatively following gastroplasty
|
following fundoplication
|
Post-Operatively
|
|
1wk
|
3mos.
|
|
Pressure (CM H20)
|
16
|
13
|
25
|
55
|
39
|
34
|
The Post-operative pressures were significantly greater
than the pre-operative pressures (P<.05). Animal experimenls by others have
demonstrated the ability of proximal gastric musculalure to funclion as a high
pressure zone when converted into a lube or when wrapped around ihe esophagus.
These sludies extend those findings to the human situation and provide a
physiologic rationale for ihe effectiveness of gastroplasty and fundoplication.
3:30 P.M. Executive
Session (Limited to Active and Senior Members) Grand Ballroom
*By invitation
TUESDAY EVENING,
APRIL 19, 1977
7:00 P.M. President's Reception Dominion Ballroom
8:00 P.M. President's Dinner and Dance Dominion
Ballroom
Attendance
open to all physicians and their ladies. Tickets must be purchased at the
registration desk by 5:00 P.M. on Monday, April 18th.
Dinner dress preferred.