Sunday Afternoon, May 18, 1958
2:00 P.M. Scientific Session: REGULAR PROGRAM -Imperial Ballroom.
37. Pulmonary Resection in the
Treatment of Tuberculosis - Experience with 1700 Cases.
Raymond J.
Barrett (by invitation), Richard Jankoska (by invitation),
J. Claude Day, Paul V. O'Rourke and E. J. O'Brien, Detroit, Mich.
A review of all pulmonary resections performed for
tuberculosis at Herman Kiefer Hospital is presented. Resection is increasingly
the method of choice so that at present only about 10% of cases are treated by
thoracoplasty - the latter being reserved for cases deemed not suitable for
resection.
A previous report giving experiences prior to 1950 with
a mortality rate of 12% is incorporated in the present resume which gives an
overall mortality rate of approximately 3% and a current mortality rate of
below 2%.
The bronchopleural fistula rate, while it has been
halved from 12% to 6% still remains the number one complication. Delays in
expansion are a frequent complication although not, in the majority of cases,
requiring further surgery. Fistula and delayed expansion are much more prone to
occur in tuberculous than in non-tuberculous resections.
Spread or reactivation of disease has become a
relatively rare happening, occurring in less than one per cent of cases in the
past five years.
The extent of resection has been steadily refined so
that pneumonectomy is now done very rarely, whereas segmental resection is
rapidly becoming the most common operation.
38. Pulmonary Infarction
Complicating Segmental Resection.
John M. Salyer and Harold N. Harrison (by
invitation), Denver, Colo.
During the past three years 13 of 398 patients having
segmental resections in the treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis have developed
a peculiar sort of postoperative difficulty. Such complications are
attributable to post-resection segmental or subsegmental infarction. In
our recent experience such untoward events alone have given a complication rate
of 3.2 per cent. Further consideration of this problem seems indicated since
the course of events which results in serious postoperative complication, to
our knowledge, has been alluded to only twice in the voluminous literature
dealing with complications following pulmonary resection.
Study of such infarcted contiguous segments removed at
subsequent thoracotomy have demonstrated that pathologic changes resulting from
venous obstruction and/or thrombosis usually begin at the intersegmental
surface and proceed centrally. Other changes such as congestion, hemorrhage,
infarction, liquefaction, occasional abscess formation and associated
organization and fibrosis have been demonstrated. Air leaks along the segmental
plane may create tension pleural spaces. If proper management is delayed,
empyema, bronchopleural fistula, delayed hemorrhage and perhaps progression of
tuberculous disease can be expected. None so diagnosed has progressed beyond
the tension pleural space stage. 12 of the 13 patients had secondary
thoracotomy from 9 to 19 days after primary resection. One was not properly
managed until 144 days had elapsed. All recovered uneventfully after the
condition was corrected. To date none have had recurrence of tuberculous
disease.
Suggestions for prevention and recommendations as to
surgical management will be discussed.
39. Creation of a
Temporary Artificial Ductus in the Surgical Correction of Ventricular Septal
Defects Associated with Severe Pulmonary Hypertension. A Two-Stage Operation.
Howard D. Sirak (by invitation) and Don M. Hosier (by invitation).
Sponsored by H.
William Clatworthy, Jr., Columbus,
Ohio
Surgical correction of interventricular septal defects
employing open-heart technique is associated with a high operative mortality
whenever severe pulmonary hypertension is present. In contrast, cases of
"atypical" ductus with a similar degree of pulmonary hypertension have been
successfully treated. Therefore, a two-stage operation was devised in order to
permit a more gradual reversal of the pathophysiology. This procedure has been
employed only in individuals who had essentially equal pressures in both the
pulmonic and systemic circulations.
At the time of the open-heart surgical correction, but
prior to the injection of heparin, an artificial ductus is created between the
ascending aorta and pulmonary artery. This is accomplished by anastomosing a
homograft, 5-6 mm. in inside diameter, in end-to-side fashion to each of these
structures at a point about 4 cm. from the heart. After a few minutes to permit
clotting at the suture lines, the open-heart surgery is accomplished in the
usual fashion. At the conclusion of the by-pass, the artificial ductus, which
had been temporarily occluded during the perfusion, is opened. After an
interval of 3 to 6 months the artificial ductus is divided through a relatively
minor operation performed through the right chest.
The smaller diameter of the artificial ductus as
compared with the original septal defect reduces but does not obliterate the
left-to-right shunt, thus allowing a partial return to the normal state. It
also serves as an escape valve for the right ventricle should the resistance in
the lungs be excessive. From a physiologic point of view, staging the repair
reduces the final operation to closure of an "atypical" ductus.
Six patients have been treated in this manner. One died
because one of the leaflets of the tricuspid valve was distorted during closure
of the septal defect and another because the hypertensive changes in the lungs
were so far advanced that very little residual shunt through the
interventricular septal defect remained. This patient was essentially an
Eisenmenger's syndrome and should not have been selected for the operation. A
discussion of clinical and laboratory findings of each of the cases and the
operative technique will be presented.
40. Corrective
Surgery in the Presence of Far Advanced Pulmonary Hypertension.
C. Walton Lillehei, Donald J.
Ferguson (by invitation) and
Richard L.
Varco, Minneapolis, Minn.
Pulmonary arteriosclerosis resulting in elevated
pulmonary pressure due to greatly increased vascular resistance is a common
accompaniment of many congenital and some acquired cardiac lesions and now that
open heart methods have been perfected has proved to be the principle limiting
factor to successful surgical therapy in these far advanced cases.
Two approaches to this problem are possible. The first
is to define certain contra-indications for surgery and then reject for
operation those patients who might be anticipated as having a high risk with
the usual treatment.
The alternative, which we have preferred, is to
consider that virtually all of these patients are basically curable if enough
knowledge concerning their pathologic physiology can be acquired. Research upon
this problem has been both experimental and clinical. The study of the lung
biopsy in correlation with these other clinical and physiologic findings
including the response to corrective surgery has been the key to progress.
First, the method of death in these patients has been
accurately identified by serial pressure measurements and other observations
during this event. Confirmation by reproduction of this picture in dogs has
been carried out. Two factors of importance have emerged: abnormal vascular
resistance and abnormal lung compliance.
With this knowledge two basic methods found of great
therapeutic value clinically have evolved. First, are the measures directed to
the lungs. These vary from (depending upon the severity of the pulmonary
vascular disease and the patient's age) the use of a closed system with aid to
the respiratory effort ranging from supply of 100% oxygen in a closed system by
a demand respirator to complete mechanical respiration at positive pressure.
Second, in the severest cases where the above methods
have been insufficient, the construction of temporary decompressing shunts at
the time of corrective surgery is necessary. The indications for, technique of,
and physiology of these lifesaving shunts is presented.
As a consequence of these measures it has been possible
to both reduce operative mortality and to extend corrective surgery to patients
previously considered inoperable. Moreover, experience has indicated that if
even these patients with such advanced states of pulmonary arteriosclerosis can
be successfully guided through this crucial period of readjustment immediately
post-correction, their lung pathology will heal in most cases in the succeeding
months. Thus, the premium upon learning how to manage these patients though
undeniably great has permitted the adoption of a considerably more optimistic
attitude concerning pulmonary hypertension.
41. Surgical
Treatment of the Tetralogy of Fallot by Open Intra-cardiac Repair.
John W. Kirklin, F. Henry Ellis, Jr. and Dwight
C. McGoon
(by invitation), Rochester, Minn.
Experience with the intracardiac repair of the tetralogy of Fallot is
now sufficiently extensive to warrant an initial critical review, both in an
effort to determine the efficacy of the method as compared to other methods and
to assess the new technical knowledge which has been gained thereby.
At the time of writing of this abstract, 60 patients
who had this particular intracardiac malformation have undergone surgical
repair of it. Data concerning these patients, as well as others operated upon
prior to the final preparation of the manuscript, form the basis of the report.
Features of the whole-body perfusion peculiar to this
particular type of intracardiac surgery are discussed. Surgical technics for
the repair of this defect are described. Although a low operative mortality
rate can be quoted for selected groups within the series, or for patients
operated upon recently, the nonsurvival rate for the entire series is
approximately 30 per cent. This mortality rate is analyzed relative to the
anatomic and technical factors which appear to have produced it. Among these is
the adequacy of repair, documented in most cases by postcardiotomy studies of
hemodynamics. The excellence of the result attainable for surviving patients by
means of intracardiac repair is demonstrated.
An attempt is made to compare the hazards and results
of this surgical technic with those of the shunt procedures, this comparison
suggesting to the authors certain tentative conclusions regarding the surgical
methods of treating the tetralogy of Fallot.
42. Atrial Septal
Defect, Secundum. Observations on One Hundred Patients Treated by Open
Operation.
Henry Swan, D.
Hywel Davies (by invitation) and
S. Gilbert Blount, Jr.
(by invitation), Denver, Colo.
This report concerns 100 consecutive patients with
atrial septal defect of the secundum variety not associated with pulmonic
stenosis, all of whom were treated by repair of the lesion under direct vision,
using general body hypothermia.
An analysis of the diagnostic features and a discussion
of the nature of the hemodynamic and structural alterations due to the
abnormality will be presented. Since almost all of these patients underwent
cardiac catheterization preoperatively, and a majority were similarly studied
postoperatively, considerable data has accumulated for study.
A wide variety of defects, of course, were observed.
The frequency of multiple defects, of associated aberrant pulmonary veins and
of aberrant entrance of the inferior vena cava into the left auricle emphasize
the importance of visual guidance in the repair of these lesions.
Ninety-three patients, including the last 56
consecutive cases, survived the procedure and are alive and well at the present
time. Careful postoperative observations on the effect of closure of the
defects on the disordered circulation has led to some opinions concerning the
relationship between the stage of the disease and the probable result of
surgery. On the basis of these observations, and the demonstrated safety (less
than 2% risk) of the current technique, our indications for surgery have
approached those which are now accepted for patent ductus arteriosus.